Adam Goodes

Started by crabapples, April 14, 2012, 07:54:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

crabapples

Anyone think theres much in adam goodes slidding with his knees. With all the injuries i dnt need him rubbed out

Bennyy

I think he will be fine

mpollock

Didn't see it ... did he do any damage to his opponent?
Did he get the guy in the head?
Was it avoidable?
Does he have any points hanging over his head?

Hard to predict the MRP ... especially given it is Goodes but these things will give you some idea.

Noz

He will get reprimanded for that.

crabapples

I only saw slow mo so hard to tell didnt do any damage though i dnt think. And no idea bout his numbers.

Bennyy

Think its on the AFL website videos if you want a look. I saw it slow on telly before.
Its probably a bit reckless but I dont think itll draw weeks

bluedreamin

Apparently he got a week in the pre-season for exactly the same incident.

The Bomber

Quote from: bluedreamin on April 14, 2012, 09:53:26 PM
Apparently he got a week in the pre-season for exactly the same incident.

yeah he has been suspended for a smiliar incident...

btw doesnt he have carry over points or a bad record so the plea wont decrease...if so i think he may get a week min

TheMailman

I don't even understand how it's reportable his knee goes straight into his leg?

Sigh. He got suspended for doing that in the preseason and no doubt MRP will probably not want him to do it again :(

mabo

#9
It looks like they both slid into the contest knee first.

http://bigpondvideo.com/AFL/440077/Goodes%20on%20report/

Not that it will probably matter, but he could defend it by saying that it would be an unreasonable expectation for him to slide head first into a contest where his opponent is clearly sliding in knee first.


**Edit**
Found the footage of the NAB report, it says he was booked for sliding in feet first (as opposed to knee first).

http://www.afl.com.au/tabid/208/default.aspx?newsid=129639

In frame 1:03 it's visible that the contact was feet first.

Grasping at straws I know, a by product have having both Fyfe and Goodes in my forward line and looking for an upside.

:(

HotTiges

can't even remember the last time someone got reported for kneeing.. would of been McKernan lol

crabapples

Damn iphone. I cant see those vid links, hoping he'll b right

The Bomber

kinda hoping the same because of Nat Fyfes injury...if it is serious

PICCOLLO

Will get a week I think.  Was reckless and there is precedent for it.