My 2010 in the right spot

[tony73]

Have re-posted this in the right forum "Rate my SC Team" with a few changes!

Back Brenden Goddard, Luke Hodge, Sam Fisher, Shannon Hurn, Tadhg Kennelly, Rick Ladson, Brad Sheppard
(Matt Maguire, Daniel Talia)       

Center Gary Ablett jnr, Mark Murphy, Bernie Vince, Luke Ball, Rhys Palmer, Tom Scully,
(Dustin Martin, Anthony Morabito)       

Ruck Dean Cox,  Jesse White
( Wade Skipper, Mathew Lobbe)       

FWD Nick Riewolt, Shaun Higgins, Brett Deledio, Mathew Pavich,  Jack Trengove, Scott Gumbleton, Phil Davis   
(Kane Lucas, Luke Tapscott)


Lots of rookies up forward so as to pick off the falling premiums through round 6-8
Opinions!

[Justin Bieber]

Great team tony.

Backs are strong but don't like goose on field. He'll play the games but likely won't score well. Will only be good for cash cow. Mids and rucks are still good. Forwards could be risky with 3 rookies there. It hink you could stand to upgrade on of them to a mid pricer at around 300k (danderfield maybe?).

For me the mids you could either put 2 rookies on field or at least downgrade one of the 3 of them to open up more cash.

[Kangamagic]

Tony,

Very impressive team, I agree with Hellopplz I wouldnt have McGuire on field if you could swap him and get someone else who should get heaps of time on ground that would be great but knowing who is the big question. Maybe Phil Davis?

Midfield : Is great.

Rucks : Is great.

Forwards : Is great also and I dont mind having those rookies on the ground they just have to play for you and hopefully you should be right and not have any short on the field or on bench and that you dont get any "Zero" scores but they are good picks.

But a great start and a solid team.

Magic

[tony73]

Cheers boys,

The rookie spots will vary depending on pre-season games and who looks like getting a gig early.

My early pick was Jesse Smith instead of Maguire but again it depends on what rookies will play, with Otten gone Tahlia or Davis may get a gig.

I probably should mention I go for the League win only as its a tough work league with cash and pride on the line so donuts dont so much matter (lost the GF last year), just not too many. In saying that I would love to improve ranking this year as my second year going at it.

[tony73]

Made a few changes now Goddard is listed as a back, Newman gets the flick. Also decided to throw Cox in over Sandi seeing as I had the cash.

Throw a blanket over the rookies until pre-season, I have listed most the pricey ones so any cheaper swaps will be a bonus.

$25k left in the bank

I am pretty happy with this team, opinions?