BundyOPs team. feedback please

[BundyOP]

4 options i believe i have this week!

option 1:clarke and bugg out. enright/scotland and yarran in
option 2: clarke and bugg out. heppel and newman in.
option 3: 1 of clarke/bugg out. enright/scotland in
option 4: hold trades

[BundyOP]

bump! need someones opinion! really lost....

wnet enright and yarran...now having second thoughts, i can't take yarran from 1 good game from many poor ones before

[charliesheen]

Clarke  > Carrots

I think Bugg/Ellis rotated should be able to average 60-70 which should be okay.  Richmond have a lot of injuries so helps Ellis a bit

Not against the Yarran idea.

[BundyOP]

thanks CS

i knew everyone would eventually convince me to get carrots....grr

its scotland, yarran n 26k
or carrots, yarran and 74k

mmm....

[charliesheen]

Carrots will be in the top 4 defenders based on 2nd half averages calling it now.  Ignore price.

[charliesheen]

I actually think you should just go

Clarke > Carrots

and don't upgrade your D7 until you are facing a donut.  Think you should be fine from a league context, because others are facing similar issues.

Ellis might dodge the sub with the number of injuries they have.

[BundyOP]

getting rid of bugg now because of his massive Be

[charliesheen]

I wouldn't worry about price drop.

I would just grab Carrots and hold out as long as you can before you are forced to trade through donut.  Then do a downgrade and grab a better defender IMO.

Docherty getting game soon with Golby out.

[BundyOP]

Thats true...the 2nd trade not needed...

Not convinced with yarran either...

Time for reverse number 3

[charliesheen]

like if your going for league I don't think its going to be high priority.  think you will be able to take wins with rookie def.

[BundyOP]

Well did reverse trades...

Annoyed at myself for havimg yarran in twice and reversing it, should of gone with gut...but only time will tell...

[charliesheen]

If you finish top 4 in your league without Yarran, I think your better off not having him.  Holding onto trade much better.

[BundyOP]

wow been awhile since ive updated or asked for help

been going pretty good.
made finals in 5/5 of my leagues, in premlim in 4/5
ranked 5183 overall, peaked last week at 4658

have 3 trades and 259,500 in bank

team is
backs: delidio, hurn, goddard, birchall, lake, carrazzo, s.shaw (bugg, bell)
mids: ablett, watson, thompson, a.swallow, j.selwood, pendles (gibson, sexton)
rucks: roughead, natanui (jenkins, stephenson)
fwds : beams, dangerfield, s.johnson, franklin, martin, goodes, zorko (treloar, smedts)

so trade options
def going lake > scotland which leaves me with 138,100 in bank
im comfortable to cover selwood with treloar and gibson have the e
thinking of trading sshaw, but he has been in good form
martin another trade out option
could also trade out trelaor and put zorko in mids for selwood...

problem is that the only good fwd i see worth getting is pav, and i can't afford him with martin or treloar...

help please!

[Ringo]

No love for Sidebottom or O'Keeffe as an alternative forward. Will still leave you around 100k cash for final upgrade next week. Upgrade Shaw to Grimes!!!

[BundyOP]

sidey is at a juicey price....think i may bring him in for treloar...
yer shaw out next week.

leaves me 68k for last trade.