Broughton ------> Adcock or Fisher

[SOS#1]

Let me know why you chose who you did.

Cheers!

[Alka]

I would keep him. Every defender has his ups and downs, there's very few who don't. If you get rid of Broughton now prepare to be annoyed by him scoring a few 100+ in a row.

If you have to trade, I'd go for Adcock. Redden and Black being out of the side for a few weeks should mean more midfield time and a lot more of the ball.

[fertalong]

I would NEVER trade broughton to any of those 2. I have him and planning to keep him, but if i was going to drop him, I would much prefer going to a premium if cash allows (Carrots, Birch, Suckling, Deledio, Goddard) or I would would downgrade to other mids like waters, malceski, hargrave.
Fisher and Adcock are likely to give you the same headaches as broughton will, but with a much lower ceiling.

[Colliwobblers]

I would NEVER trade broughton to any of those 2. I have him and planning to keep him, but if i was going to drop him, I would much prefer going to a premium if cash allows (Carrots, Birch, Suckling, Deledio, Goddard) or I would would downgrade to other mids like waters, malceski, hargrave.
Fisher and Adcock are likely to give you the same headaches as broughton will, but with a much lower ceiling.

Yes what he said exactly

[SOS#1]

Is broughton playing a different role this year tho? And wif mundy to come back n Barlow playing part games, surely this couldn't help his cause?

[Windigo]

Out of those options?

No to both of them.

[Plastic Boy]

You want to trade to these guys??? Are they any better for consistency, I don't think so

[Holz]

There are very few players i would get rid of broughton for, Lids and Goddard if im upgrading waters ,eski hargreave or clarke if im downgrading and can use the cash immediately to help the team. If your not doing that keep broughton i think he will out average both of those guys.

[deekay]

Redden being out of the side for a few weeks should mean more midfield time and a lot more of the ball.

whats he done?!

[bigred]

hepple