Is the trade worth it?

[gillies]

Trade: coniglio (who is on my bench) out for green
             Gibbs out for pendlebury

Is it worth it?

[hardnut]

2 trades for only a modest improvement in your team. I don't think there is enough evidence to be sure Greene will be much better than Coniglio over the journey. I do expect Pendles to outscore Gibbs but both are premo's so I'd just let things roll with Gibbs for a while. Pendles can come later via traditional rookie upgrade methods.

[Ricochet]

what does the rest of your midfield look like gillies?

[gillies]

Ablett, Watson, selwood, montagna, gibbs, magner
(shiel, coniglio)

[Ricochet]

Ablett(Rd 13 Bye), Watson(Rd 12 Bye) , selwood(Rd 12 Bye) , montagna(Rd 13 Bye) , gibbs(Rd 13 Bye) , magner
(shiel, coniglio)

Are you worried about byes?? if you are and want to trade gibbs out, i would look to a round 11 bye in maybe S.Thommo, Rockliff, Redden or Boyd.

[gillies]

Do you think trading to Boyd would be worthwhile?

[Ricochet]

Do you think trading to Boyd would be worthwhile?

definitely, especially him playing the saints this week.

[Ricochet]

Do you think trading to Boyd would be worthwhile?

definitely, especially him playing the saints this week.

** he got 143 against them last year, if you need more to persuade you

[thatguy]

Boyd is your man

[gillies]

is gibbs to boyd worth a trade? what do you think gibbs will do for the year?

[big_cox21]

i would just let it go, not worth a straight swap between two premos imo. and your mids are already really strong so no need to try strengthen them by going sideways this early. you picked players for a reason give them time, theres a long way to go