Shiel or Coniglio?

[sj9177]

Hey Guys

Sorry this one has me in a bind

Obviously Coniglio did better last week, but i have a vibe Shiel is going to step up big time this week

Any thoughts?

[Ringo]

Shiel was obviously a bit short of match fitness due to his appendix removal and can only improve with match fitness under his belt bt whether he can match Coniglio this week is the question.  Go with gut feel but imo probably needs another week to regain full fitness.

[jfitty]

Tough one. I think Coniglio will definitely score better than last week, but Shiel will most likely play a full game and going by his first quarter last week could score big. I'd say Shiel, only just

[Luigi197]

Pre-season i would've said Shiel, and i am still tipping him to do better than Coniglio in the long run.
But in my gut, i would say, for this week, Coniglio over Shiel. Why? Because we never know how cautios Sheedy will be, and we have more certainty in Coniglio NOT being the sub.