Inseparable

Started by Madsnake, March 30, 2012, 10:31:24 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who will have the best average come end of the year?

Daisy Thomas
Jobe Watson
Pick someone else

Madsnake

I am finding it impossible to separate these two players, both looking like they'll improve on their average of last year but these two are killing me...

Thoughts?

2 large cokes

if he stays fit jobe can be top 5. if daisy is at his peak I think can only just squeeze in the top 10. could be wrong but imo jobe is everything to the bombers where as daisy is behind pendles, swan and will find it more difficult to score consistently.

Madsnake

Quote from: 2 large cokes on March 30, 2012, 10:38:42 AM
if he stays fit jobe can be top 5. if daisy is at his peak I think can only just squeeze in the top 10. could be wrong but imo jobe is everything to the bombers where as daisy is behind pendles, swan and will find it more difficult to score consistently.
See i looked at it in a different way, Jobe as a lot of pressure to perform and will probably cop the tag and is a tad injury prone, daisy is very durable and doesn't cop the tag because he has so much quality around him.


m-ry

Jobe will avg over 25 Possies a games no matter what. If he's tag it only makes more of them contested

Madsnake

Quote from: m-ry on March 30, 2012, 11:31:20 AM
Jobe will avg over 25 Possies a games no matter what. If he's tag it only makes more of them contested
And Daisy won't?

I'm very surprised with the lack of Excitement for Daisy..

JBs-Hawks

Daisy will get the tag cos Pendles and Swan are pretty much untaggable whereas its a lot easy to shut daisy out of a game.

owenbond007

jobe will go forward and kick goals too. Good overhead mark reckon hell kick at least 1 a game ontop of 25+ possies a game. Could be the pick of the year if his hammys can make it through a season.

TMurphBROWNLOW

wow I could not believe my eyes when I saw the poll count! I would've thought daisy would be equally matched or even higher!
he is the king unique magpie of the year! absolute gun, will give you what you want each week as he'll receive tagger #3 or #4 if teams have them! having him and either swan or pendles could pay off big time! or go the other way... but I have a gut feeling he will play like a superstar!

Madsnake

Quote from: TMurphBROWNLOW on March 30, 2012, 12:35:28 PM
wow I could not believe my eyes when I saw the poll count! I would've thought daisy would be equally matched or even higher!
he is the king unique magpie of the year! absolute gun, will give you what you want each week as he'll receive tagger #3 or #4 if teams have them! having him and either swan or pendles could pay off big time! or go the other way... but I have a gut feeling he will play like a superstar!

Mate, i was just starting to settle on Watson..
But i completely agree with you, he's an absolute superstar, so little hype around him, he will be an excellent unique sitting next to my mids of Rockliff, Ablett and Scotty T.

Still 50/50 though..
FLOWER

TMurphBROWNLOW

he's the forgotten magpie in a brilliant team well-known for it's dynamic duo. he does the little amazing things and doesn't get noticed! same goes for Luke ball. I'm not going to hype him up after he became my most hated player after the prelim last year.

if you want to go unique pick Watson. if you want to be super unique go thomas. you can't really split them... so you can't go wrong with either. at the end of the season they'll be very close in average points!

Madsnake

Quote from: TMurphBROWNLOW on March 30, 2012, 02:56:45 PM
he's the forgotten magpie in a brilliant team well-known for it's dynamic duo. he does the little amazing things and doesn't get noticed! same goes for Luke ball. I'm not going to hype him up after he became my most hated player after the prelim last year.

if you want to go unique pick Watson. if you want to be super unique go thomas. you can't really split them... so you can't go wrong with either. at the end of the season they'll be very close in average points!

Now that i think about it, it probably doesn't actually matter who i pick, their scores will be very similar.
so maybe i should just go Daisy purely for the uniqueness of him..

TMurphBROWNLOW

go for you life buddy!

Chelskiman

Watson is going to smash it this year.  Could easily average between 110 and 115.

Madsnake

Quote from: Chelskiman on March 30, 2012, 03:45:05 PM
Watson is going to smash it this year.  Could easily average between 110 and 115.

Who's to say daisy can't average that?
The thing about Daisy is that he's not going to get injured.. but Watson..