RATE "TAMBLING ON ICE"

[pim fortuyn]

Tambling on Ice:

Def: Scotland, Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Hargrave, Clarke, Ellis (Bugg, Morris)

Mid: Pendlebury, Boyd, Ablett, Selwood, Conglio, Magner (Shiel, Mcdonald)

Ruc: Mcevoy, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

For: Franklin, Fyfe, Robinson, Martin, Sidebottom, D. Smith, Kennedy (Hall, Couch)

Spare Cash: $1,400

Rate mine and i'll rate yours! Any advice is very much appreciated

[PCR10]

Nice side,
like your backs maybe bit weak with both clarke and hargrave. It will take Clarke a bit of time to get back into the swing and pace of the game! keep one and get rid of the other. upgrade one to waters.

Midfield didnt like coniglio for his price tag but thats too late now, better options for less money

rucks very good

Forwards are a touch underdone - or sidebottom needs to be upgraded to a cloke, chapman etc Keep martin he is a gun! i like Robison as a unique could pay off!!

9/10

Suss out my side if you want

Backs:
Goddard, Deledio ,Shaw, Birchall, Waters, Ellis, Bugg
MORRIS, WILKES

Mids:
Swan, Ablett, Boyd, Mitchell, Ledger, A. Kennedy
MCDONALD, MAGNER

Rucks:
Mumford, Giles
REDDEN, STEPHENSON

Forwards:
Franklin, Fyfe, Cloke, Martin, Dangerfield, Smith, Pfieffer
HALL, COUCH

$10,000 left in the kitty

[jamez_1983]

nice team mate! 9/10
only change i would make would be dickson instead of couch, but thats a minor.

thoughts on mine?

DEF: Scotland, Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, MClarke, Ellis, Bugg (Smedts, Morris
MID: Ablett, Boyd, Selwood, S.Thompson, Coniglio , Magner ( Shiel , Gibson)
RUC: Cox , Giles (Redden, Stephenson)
FWD: Franklin, Fyfe, Goodes , Martin, Dangerfield, Porplyzia, D.Smith ( A.Kennedy , Pfeiffer)

$43,000 left over

[PCR10]

Porplyzia is too much of a risk mate, his shoulder is that bad it could pop out wiping his arse!!!

[pim fortuyn]

both of you have almost perfect sides, except that i dont like dangerfield. he should still do well enough and probs get 80-85 average, but i really dont think he will become a keeper and get up to 450-500k value, and i think you/I can get better cash cowing money from rookies in the forward line. same with the porpoise - he should make a fair bit of dough, but not as good of a return as other rookies such as kennedy, smith, pfeiffer and potentially hall.
because im so low on cash, my only real alternative is to trade scotland down to a mid pricer in order to free up cash to upgrade clarke - would you guys go for scotland & clarke or waters & golby/conca?

[PCR10]

Go The Golby scenario, Conca will get the vest i a certain!!! Who would you take dangerfield out for i thought of uprgading him to Waite other than that i cant find much more!!