Thoughts and general feedback on team

Started by wyldie36, March 29, 2012, 10:26:31 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

wyldie36

Here is my side.



If this was your side what would you be looking at.

Missed out on Mcdonnald pretty spewing.

Feedback Appreciated.

Cheers,

Wyld

Rowy

You could leave you team as is and would be good for league comp.But i would make a couple of changes.
Wilkes has good js but will score low
Hall to bench and Dickson starting
Also would consider Lake for either Broughton or Birchall, he potentially could score better than both.
Use extra cash to upgrade Porps to danger Sidey or J Roo.
Good luck

wyldie36

cheers man, what are your thoughts on leaving minimal cash in bank?
after the upgrade?

I'm always a bit tentative on using all my cash, not that 22k is alot but might be enough to swap rookies if I ened to before round 3.

Yeh I am only chasing a league win here.

wyldie36

You think Lake will have a better scoring year than Porp?

Bill Manspeaker

nice team mate, one change i'd make is Wilkes -> Ellis.. as Rowy said Wilkes has good JS but will score really bad, whereas Ellis has been named on the wing for Richmond.. there's always a chance of him being sub though. IMO it's worth the risk

wyldie36

I think i'm more of a risk taker, Ellis in, I have enjoyed watching him so far.

Still considering that 3 way change with broughton > lake....  porp > sidebum

Lake makes me nervous, or should I be more nervous with porp... maybe that's the question?

Bill Manspeaker

that's a tough one.. Broughton and Sidebottom will probably score around the same.. and i think Lake will average more than Porps, if he can get back into form he should be a machine.

i'd probably go Lake and Sidebottom.. but it does make your backline look a little weak