Broughton or Heater

[enzedder]

As the title suggests.
I like Broughton but can afford Heater. Just because I can afford him though isn't enough for me to do it.
Thoughts.

[ajjewell]

By the end of the season I can't see there being too much difference between these 2 players

[port2012]

i got both

[sid3bysid3]

Both for me

[Brad1976]

I have both. But if I had to pick one Shaw.

[4INAROW]

if you have to pick, shaw by a mile

[enzedder]

Thanx all...reckon I still might go for Broughton...bit cheaper and midfield possibility the main reasons why. I expected Shaw to be most favoured in the poll but there are obviously others thinking along the same lines as me so I'm happy to do the less favoured player in this case.

[Ringo]

I believe that with Pies injuries in backline (Maxwell, Brown and Tarrant) Shaw may not have the running role he had and as a result may fall in value and be an upgarde target later on.  So Broughton is probably better balue at a cheaper price.