Wingard or McCarthy

[bkp130]

As above Looking at either mccarthy. Hoping for a bit year from him but not sure if he is worth the extra cash over wingard. Thanks in advance for your replies

[eagles929406]

can see wingard wearing that dreaded vest a lot this season, like the gaff of last year

[port2012]

as a port fan i dont see wingard playing alot of games, ports guna have strong team round 1,
he will get named but will have to play well to keep his spot,

with rodan broadbent brett ebert slopek surjan all set not to be picked round 1

[GlassHarmonium]

has to be mcarthy better js and will av between 60-80 i believe

[quinny88]

your looking at 2 guys 100k+ in price difference, not really a fair comparrison.. mcarthy clearly

wingard or pfieffer on the other hand would be a bit tougher

[4INAROW]

pfeiffer by far coz wingard currently hasn't got the capacity to run out a full game, although if pfeiffer doesn't perform early in some games he may get the red vest.

on the other hand, being port adelaide, it's possible that any if not all of their 22 will play like shower early and have to come off, so im not sure.