Final Defender

Started by ENYGMA, March 25, 2012, 05:36:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which Defender?

Beau Waters
5 (23.8%)
Paul Duffield
4 (19%)
Mitchell Golby
3 (14.3%)
Christian Howard
2 (9.5%)
Brian Lake
7 (33.3%)

Total Members Voted: 2

ENYGMA

Which defender should I use my last 350k on? This is how I rank them.

Waters
Pros: Great scorer and player for a good upcoming team. Cheap for his potential output 80+ ave
Cons: Huge injury risk

Duffman
Pros: Generally consistent performances of 65-85 pts. A real defender
Cons: Sometimes gets the lockdown role which only equates to 45-65 pts.

Golby
Pros: Young and good preseason. Apparently were it not for an ACL he would have been a top 10 draft pick.
Cons: Just don't know much about him or the Brisbane defense to be honest.

Howard
Pros: Young gun. Ball magnet moved from midfield to defense. Definitely has the coaches backing.
Cons: 2nd year. Maybe cop a vest or two? Might be a little inconsistent and risky for my liking.

Lake
Pros: Proven scorer in the past. Dirt cheap.
Cons: Over 30. Will the body hold up. Will he reach great heights this year or just putter along?

nathan11

Looking at how you rate them you don't expect anyone to be a keeper so I picked lake runs on the board and has point to prove to the new coach will earn good money to upgrade him quick

Ricochet

Quote from: ENYGMA on March 25, 2012, 05:36:51 PM
Which defender should I use my last 350k on? This is how I rank them.

Waters
Pros: Great scorer and player for a good upcoming team. Cheap for his potential output 80+ ave
Cons: Huge injury risk

Duffman
Pros: Generally consistent performances of 65-85 pts. A real defender
Cons: Sometimes gets the lockdown role which only equates to 45-65 pts.

Golby
Pros: Young and good preseason. Apparently were it not for an ACL he would have been a top 10 draft pick.
Cons: Just don't know much about him or the Brisbane defense to be honest.

Howard
Pros: Young gun. Ball magnet moved from midfield to defense. Definitely has the coaches backing.
Cons: 2nd year. Maybe cop a vest or two? Might be a little inconsistent and risky for my liking.

Lake
Pros: Proven scorer in the past. Dirt cheap.
Cons: Over 30. Will the body hold up. Will he reach great heights this year or just putter along?


says it all