Which premium & rookie combo?

[Higgins07]

Had Rockliff in my team for the most part of the preseason but recently I've been having some doubts whether he can step it up again.
I've always had a soft spot for Boyd but unfortunately inorder to make the Rockliff --> Boyd trade I'll need to sacrifice Pfeiffer for a cheaper Fwd rookie.

What do you guys think?

Thanks

[pavs nose]

Boyd monstered the nab cup. When in doubt go the player you prefer, in you case, Boyd. Can't go wrong with either tho

[Obese Arachnid]

With two options like that I think everyone/majority will go Rockliff & Michelle.

Option one has a probable top ten mid with a mature age rookie.

Option two has an out & out gun in Boyd & a not named rookie.

If you had of named a rookie with Boyd, the outcome might be different.

People don't like the unknown.

[tigertops]

if u can find a reliable rookie boyd and that rookie will be the way to go.
safety option is to go the other way....
all depends on the rookie tho

[Colliwobblers]

Rocky is a star and get the best rook named to go with him. You still want to bring in 2 or 3 mid premiums depending on your setup so I think both of these guys will be in the top bunch and you can't go wrong with either premo, if the one you don't get is smashing it bring him in when you are doing upgrades..