Mccarthy vs. Masten vs. Caddy

[bkimm32]

Kane Lucas would also be a decent pickup?

I would be all over Masten, but I'm running 4 prems and 4 rookies in the engine room this season.

steer clear of lucas for SC his disposal efficiency is shower 26% last outing.

Wow, that is almost unheard of.

[PICCOLLO]

I like mccarthy and masten.  Mccarthy has been killing it in the Nab buts its curious theyve been using him so sparingly.  Masten JS okay?  Was doubting that a bit.

[mpollock]

At the moment i have the following midfield:

Ablett, Boyd, Mitchell, Masten, Parker, Caddy (McDonald, Magner)

May lock in Magner even if not picked round 1 ... would have gone Neale as well (prob back rd 2) but didn't want both my bench players not playing round 1 .. hence McDonald is a safe bet (unless Shiel is named as he played in the twos last week).

I think McCarthy will be vested a lot based on pre-season.
Masten is going to kill it ... if not ... easy to downgrade to McCarthy if I am wrong about him!!

If you start with McCarthy and Masten kills it instead ... you would have spent the money elsewhere and will struggle to get him ...

[ando_10]

my only issue is with these fellas they are wide open for the green vest/red vest so i dunno im a bit iffy about picking these guys i like masten the most of them

thought about brad ebert?

[ubeaut]

I think Masten is injured. MCarthy may get more oppurtunity at Port. He will be enjoying being an important player instead of a fringe one and will make the most of it. Caddy is a gun though. MCarthy just.

[4INAROW]

yeh masten out for 2 weeks minimum

[Jay]

caddy vs conglio?

[bkp130]

I like mccarthy

In a port midfield thats not strong he will flourish. had a good pre season as well