Josh Caddy or Dylan Shiel?

[Wes Mantooth]

my mids is currently:

D.Swan, M.boyd, J.Selwood, Coniglio, Shiel and Jmac (C.Smith, J.Magner)

Should i get rid of clay smith for caddy?

Do you have the extra 150K too? caddy is 249K

CADDY is only $218k and imo the best 218 you will spend in SC this year.

my bad - I was talking DT prices, sorry.

Gees, if I were playing SC he would have been my first selected at that price.

[azza707]

yeah i agree, can't believe some people are saying Caddy has had an average Nab. played well in that 49% game time as already stated and then in the last game he scored the same as ablett, and is scoring at 101 points per minute. i know this is dream team wise, but he will find the footy and is an above average user of the ball. has also been to arizona twice.

To be honest, i don't think you will can go wrong with any of shiel and coniglio for the cheaper options, and caddy and parker for the more expensive mid pricers. i do think that caddy and parker will average between 15-20 points higher than the other two. so i guess it comes down to personal preference and structure, in that what you can do with the extra cash and how byes will turn out.

one thing to note however, is that longmire in a recent video about DT value picks, has highlights luke parker as his choice, because he will be playing him a lot more through the middle.

Also on ledger, he looks so promising, but i would steer clear for now unfortunately :( I drew up a mock team of the saints the other day and i just can't see him getting a full game in the midfield, will most likey play reserves or be the sub on a few occasions.
and no he doesn't play off halfback. he's a hard nut, tough inside midfielder, similar to lenny hayes actually. if lenny does go down he may juuuust slip into the side. still to hard to tell though and i think your better off going with the other options stated.

[Wes Mantooth]

Is there the chance Caddy will be the sub? If not, who will be? I don't have too much of an idea about the Suns team this year.

[azza707]

i doubt he will be. unless he has an injury and comes back as the sub to get back into things, but i doubt it. has been to arizona twice so is mega fit and they would want to get games into this kid cos he is an absolute jet. had elite fantasy numbers as a kid. think he will round off the midfield nicely with ablett, rischitelli and swallow