Pav vs Goodes vs Fyfe

[jamesalex]

Hi,

I'm tossing up between getting Goodes, Pav or Fyfe.

If I get Goodes, that means that I do not have the flexibilty to change my teams structure after the partial lockout, going from a rookie ruck strucutre to a 3 rookie mid structure. I reckon Goodes will score higher than Pav over the season, and a little bit higher than Fyfe.

If I get Fyfe, i have the structure-change flexibility, because i could get Pav for him.

Thoughts?
Thanks.

[Southstorm]

If Goodes has a typical season, he'll give a lacklusture performance at the start of the year and a top performance in the second half which makes him a great upgrade target.

Pav is better than Fyfe, but Pav is now in the 30's while Fyfe's career is comparitively just starting. Thus, I'd go for Fyfe because he has more promise this season.

Don't hold me to my word though

[enzedder]

Fyfe>Goodes>Pav

[jamesalex]

8 votes for Fyfe- Do you reckon he'll really do that well?

[jamesalex]

bump. gotta decide before lockout!

[Colliwobblers]

fyfe - pav - goodes

thats from round 1 but in terms of who i would most want from mid season onwards,

goodes - pav (if perfroming) - fyfe.

Reasoning - fyfe in great form. Not sure how pav will go playing ONLY as a key fwd. Goodes starts every season well worse than he finishes it. Pav will be rested if lyons has his way tho cant see pav signing up for tiem OFF the field just not like him to rest..

[jamesalex]

fyfe - pav - goodes

thats from round 1 but in terms of who i would most want from mid season onwards,

goodes - pav (if perfroming) - fyfe.

Reasoning - fyfe in great form. Not sure how pav will go playing ONLY as a key fwd. Goodes starts every season well worse than he finishes it. Pav will be rested if lyons has his way tho cant see pav signing up for tiem OFF the field just not like him to rest..

Thanks for the reply, i agree Goodes would be a great upgrade target, i just thought that while i had the cash i might as well grab him, but i think i might go Fyfe now..