Kennedy vs Hall

[Tom_16]

Leaning towards kennedy as he is named for GWS tomorrow but hall is a mature aged recruit and i don't want to end up with too many GWS players (bringing in kennedy would mean i have 6). who would you choose and why? Thanks

[lolrocket]

I have both. I wouldn't be too worried about Hall's JS. He has played the NAB games he could and done pretty well. He is also 22 or something and has been playing senior footy in the TSL so he's unlikely to be rested as often as the pure rooks.

[Zombie2.5]

Here you should check this thread out. http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,52152.0.html
i voted hall btw

[Mr.Craig]

Hall - I have absolutely no idea what the best 22 at GC would be so that's a bit off putting. Plus there aren't any Champion Data stats to analyse from his time down in Tassie last year. And he's already been injured once already this year.

I'm not sure I could pick him with much confidence.

Kennedy isn't exactly solid gold himself. Hopefully he's added a few kilos (Prospectus has him at 71kg). Had a good run in TAC last year averaging 25 disposals but I think he'll be one of those guys in heavy rotation. Still, I've decided to go with him.

[Tom_16]

Here you should check this thread out. http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,52152.0.html
i voted hall btw

Cheers mate

[Tom_16]

Hall - I have absolutely no idea what the best 22 at GC would be so that's a bit off putting. Plus there aren't any Champion Data stats to analyse from his time down in Tassie last year. And he's already been injured once already this year.

I'm not sure I could pick him with much confidence.

Kennedy isn't exactly solid gold himself. Hopefully he's added a few kilos (Prospectus has him at 71kg). Had a good run in TAC last year averaging 25 disposals but I think he'll be one of those guys in heavy rotation. Still, I've decided to go with him.

Thanks for that although what you said kinda turned me off both of them..

[essendon2]

Hall - I have absolutely no idea what the best 22 at GC would be so that's a bit off putting. Plus there aren't any Champion Data stats to analyse from his time down in Tassie last year. And he's already been injured once already this year.

I'm not sure I could pick him with much confidence.

Kennedy isn't exactly solid gold himself. Hopefully he's added a few kilos (Prospectus has him at 71kg). Had a good run in TAC last year averaging 25 disposals but I think he'll be one of those guys in heavy rotation. Still, I've decided to go with him.

Thanks for that although what you said kinda turned me off both of them..

hahahaha +1