swallow vs scotty thompson

[scotty_222]

which one and why?
leaning towards scotty coz he has a much better bye.
swallow a better scorer tho.

[quinny88]

both will avg around the same so doesnt matter to much

[mudgee]

Thompson has an easier draw and on (what should be) an improving team... So I would choose him. Then again, I may be a little biased being a Crows supporter!  :P

[Free Kick]

Toss of the coin mate, I've locked in Swallow.

Ave of 111 last season and should improve again with another year under his belt and captains hat on..  Good luck8)

[scotty_222]

ahh decisions.. i had them both before i looked at the byes. now i have to choose one
i think scotty thompson is the way to go. so i will change swallow to jelwood

[charliesheen]

Would take Swallow personally.

[meow meow]

Scotty T eats dud teams for breakfast. The Crows have the easiest draw ever, so Thommo will be full this year.

[devize]

Swallow. North have a good fixture too, they play GC, GWS, Essendon and WB twice with the GWS game coming in the grand final week if you're going for league wins. Expecting him to have a pretty big year, was one of my first picked.

[quinny88]

Swallow. North have a good fixture too, they play GC, GWS, Essendon and WB twice with the GWS game coming in the grand final week if you're going for league wins. Expecting him to have a pretty big year, was one of my first picked.

How is playing essendon and the dogs twice such a good thing? there not that bad, both a good chance of top 8

[bottlemart]

I have swallow locked in, so he is my choice.

I'm currently trying to decide on who for my 4th mid.  Scotty Thompson or Ryan Griffen. 

Or do I try and free up some extra cash somewhere to get Boyd?

[meow meow]

Griffen has a broken finger and might miss round 1. Consider the handball king. Will jump up to 2010 levels again now that he's not being wasted as a tagger.

[FonFatty]

Swallow will have a blinder this season & I believe he is another class compared to S Thompson. Swallow could be in the top 3 midfielders by seasons end.

[Knowall]

As a crows supporter id be surprised if Thommo improves on last year,  in fact Im expecting his scores to go slightly downhill by about 5 or so.  This is mainly due to the rise of players like Sloane and Danger and probally Vince and VB as well.  Not all the crows players can improve.

Therefore I'd probally pick Swallow because I think hes more likely to improve.

Not really a fan of either tho tbh.  Maybe Priddis?