McCarthy or Caddy as the 4th midfielder would love to know peoples thoughts?

[conor94]

 :-\ \hellp is needed

[Torpedo10]

I'd go McCarthy just because his got an guaranteed spot and should score well. Caddy has had good Pre-Season form but will he keep it up?

[scotty_222]

really interested in mccarthy. i reckon he will end up being a top midfielder for port
at the end of the year

[conor94]

yeah its a tough one i believe being a collingwood supporter that mccarthey is a gun just dident get opportunity at collingwood and would easily be one of ports best midfielders already although caddy is my tip for rising star along with shiel and maybe kavanagh from essendon

[Bruizer81]

Surely L. Parker must be an option if you are considering Mccarthy

[devize]

i believe being a collingwood supporter that mccarthey is a gun

I'm a Collingwood supporter and I thought he was terrible.