Please help the WEAPONS team

[wardie]

hi guys,

Havent had much time to dedicate to SC this year so this is my first draft of a team, Please let me know of any improvements or suggestions.

BACKS: GOD, LIDS, SUCKLING, LAKE, HARGRAVE, ELLIS, DARLEY (BUGG, MORRIS)
MID: PENDLES, SWAN, GAJ, SELWOOD, CADDY, PFIFFER, (SHIEL, MAGNER)
RUCK: LUEY, GILES (BIG O, REDDEN)
FOR: BUDDY, FYFE, MARTIN, JROO, DANGER, PORP, D.SMITH (CAMERON, KENNEDY)

Rooks are a bit all over the place until team's are named but any suggestions would be appreciated!

Cheers,

[wardie]

Any help would be appreciated guys!

[Ringo]

Backs: See some weaknesses here - Do not consider Suckling D3 ok at D4 Would only select one of Lake or Hargrave.
MIds: 4 super prems
Rucks: With the 1.3 Ruck strategy there is risk here.  Berger has not been impressive in NAB Cup or club trials. Has been usually a slow starter to season as well.  Maybe look at Cox as super prem to reduce risk.
Forwards: Sound here - J Roo may be nice unique at F4.

[wardie]

had a bit more of a play and ended up with what I think is a more settled line up.

BACKS: GOD, LIDS, MALCESKI, LAKE, HARGRAVE, ELLIS, DARLEY (BUGG, MORRIS)
MID: PENDLES, SWAN, GAJ, SELWOOD, CADDY, PFIFFER, (SHIEL, MAGNER)
RUCK: MUMMY, GILES (BIG O, REDDEN)
FOR: BUDDY, FYFE, MARTIN, JROO, DANGER, PORP, D.SMITH (CAMERON, KENNEDY)

Still not sold on the back half but i think if MALCESKI can return to form of 2 years ago then he will be a keeper and score in the top 7-10 defenders and become a keeper. Was tossing up between MAL and DUFFMAN