give us a sus, and tell me if i screwed up the rookies!

Started by Unknown42, March 23, 2012, 01:14:53 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Unknown42

ok wassup guys

haven't looked at dt in over 2 weeks now because of study, kind of rushed this, can yous guys let me know if ive missed any injuries or rookies not playing! cheers

BACKS
SCOTLAND. H, GODDARD. B, SHAW. H, HEPPELL. D, HARGRAVE. R, CLARKE. M, ELLIS. B (DARLEY. S, HEATH. C)

MIDFIELDERS
SWAN. D, ABLETT. G, DAL SANTO. N, JUDD. C, MEREDITH. B, SHIEL. D (STEVENS. K, MCDONALD. J)

RUCKS
COX. D, SANDILANDS. A (GILES. J, STEPHENSON. O)

FORWARDS
FRANKLIN. L, GOODES. A, DANGERFIELD. P, BETTS. E, LYNCH. T T, PFEIFFER. D, CAMERON. J (DENNIS-LANE. T, LYNCH. M)

1,700 left

Jukes

Take out Heath, Meredith, Betts, Lynch, Dennis-Lane and Lynch.

Mr.Craig

...and Darley, Dal Santo, Judd, Pfeiffer, Stevens...

I actually like your T.Lynch pick. He might be a good unique. But yeah, you have quite a bit of work to do to whip that team into shape. Obviously your strong points are the backs and rucks but the other positions really suffer because of it. 

Giles looks like averaging a solid high 70's so spending all that extra cash to start with Sandi just seems wasted, especially when so many other coaches are going with the 1 premium, 3 rookie ruck setup. If it goes wrong then you're in the same boat as everyone else anyway. I really think you need to turn Betts into a premium and Dal Santo/Judd into guys you are positive will be top 6 mids so you don't end up wasting trades upgrading them.

jamez_1983

Players to drop IMO.
DEF - Darley, Heath
MID - Meredith, Jmac, Kstevens.
RUC - Sandi
FWD - MLynch, Dennis-lane, Betts

Replace with-
Def - two named rookies (morris, hombsch, tomlinson, smedts)
Mid - replace with named rookies (coniglio is a must)
Ruc - you can easily make alot of cash here and bring in redden like everyone else. your other option is to bring in a mid pricer like Hmac or the last option is get a unique like Jacobs or Ryder (both should have a good year).
Fwd - upgrade betts to premo and replace others with rookies that are named (DSmith, Kennedy, Hall, etc)

I like your strategy with the semi unique picks through the mids, but your whole team looks like a combination of everyrisk strategy known to man.

you will either win or come last ;)

Unknown42

alright cheers, clearly screwed up big time.
where can i find out where the named rookies,  is there a site or...

Unknown42

UPDATED TEAM


Defenders
Heath Scotland, Brendon Goddard, Heath Shaw, Dyson Heppel, Ryan Hargrave, Marty Clarke, Brandon Ellis ( Tomas Bugg, Jacob Townsend)

Midfielders
Dane Swan, Matthew Boyd, Gary Ablett, Marc Murphy, Josh Caddy, Stephen Coniglio (Dylan Shiel, James Magner)

Rucks
Dean Cox, Jonathan Giles (Jarrad Redden, Orren Stephenson)

Forwards
Lance Franklin, Adam Goodes, Nick Riewoldt, Angus Monfries, Tom T. Lynch, Darren Pfeiffer, Jeremy Cameron (Devon Smith, Billie Smedts)

Not so sure about monfries, could pay off.
is there anyone better than josh caddy for that price ?
thought and critism wanted!

Zombie2.5

i disagree coniglio is NOT a must, hes a bonus if u have the money
IMO i wouldnt have caddy + coniglio only one, downgrade other to rook(clay smith maybe?)
id get another premo in fwds for roo or monfries
backs and rucks are fine.

Backs: Solid, id get lids in there though maybe in scottys place?(hes old now might still do good though)
Mids Perfect EXCEPT the Caddy/Coniglio mentioned above, just too much money, only one.
Rucks: 1/3 is fine just ordinary.
Forwards: Like  said you need 2 guns for roo and monfries, are youu sure you dont have more money?
and maybe one less fwd rook and have a midpricer instead (gray,sidey,danger)
7/10