Rate My Team

[mophead222]

B.Goddard, B.Deledio, B.Lake, B.Ellis, S.Morris, T.Bugg, M.Clarke - S.Darley, B.Smedts

S.Pendlebury, G.Ablett, D.Swan, J.Caddy, D.Pfeiffer, J.Mcdonald - T.Ledger, A.Miles

D.Cox, S.Mumford - J.Giles, J.Redden

L.Franklin, N.Fyfe, T.Cloke, D.Martin, N.Riewoldt, D.Smith, A.Treloar - A.Hall, C.Hampton

$379,700 Left.


Thoughts Please?

[DCAK]

Hi Mophead,

DEF: Too light on, you need to buy 1 x more prem, use your cash! -1
MID: Strong. I rate your choice of Caddy.
Ruck: Super strong
FWD: I don't like the fact you have 3 x GWS rookies, what if they have a bad week? -1

8/10 - Good luck mate.

[mophead222]

Thanks man,

Yer your right about the backs, im just not sold on many of the others and not sure who to get. Probably heater.

Also im not very educated on many of the foward rookie options this year, any reccomendations??

cheers

[DCAK]

For DEF: look at Suckling, Birchall, Broughton, Heppell
As for FWD rookies,Tory Dickson (WB) played well on the weekend, Saad/Milera (StK) are also options, Weedon (WC) has been getting a run.

[tor01doc]

Extra defender ideally not from Carlton, Hawthorn, Richmond or St Kilda. R13 bye. Leaves you Broughton, Enright, Adcock and the pick of them - Heater 'the Cheater' Shaw.

Pendles too $ so save by getting Selwood for almost $100K less. Get Pendles later.

Like your forwards. Some will not approve of NRoo and Cloke is not my favorite but seems to score OK.

1 premiums and no wonder with so much money left in the bank. Spend up. You should have 13 or even 14 premiums to start.

If you get to 13 or so, Caddy will start to look like an indulgence.

Forward rookies - always difficult - I like D Smith GWS DPP / J Cameron GWS / Weedon / Cripps / Dickson / Smedts / Hall / Couch

Good luck.

[johnnytheboy1]

Backs: Not a fan of Smedt also this line has too many rookies you need at least 1 premium more
Mids: Very good midfield the only change i would make would be Pfeiffer to Kennedy or Magner
Rucks: 2 Premium Rucks what most teams need.
Fwds: Looks strong enough hope Cloke scores heavily for you.

Overall This team is unbalanced and will struggle against other teams 7/10

[tor01doc]

jtb1 - look at his stash of cash though.

If he spends it this team can work.

[mophead222]

I have pfeiffer pending his upgrade and for the mpp link.

Im not so sure on picking magner untill he is named in the side and healthy (FINGERS CROSSED)

Ill possibly bring in gerrick weedon in my foward line.

I think ill slide things around and bring in heater to my backline.

Thanks for the assistance gents :)  much appreciated

[tor01doc]

Hey mophead,

Why so many boos?

You seem reasonable.

Cheers

[mophead222]

I made a typo in a post and everyone had a go at me for it, so i said everyone F off.
People took offence and boo'd me like crazy.

Quite dissapointing though.

[tor01doc]

 ;)