Help required

[JDawg]

Ok I'm close to my final team but I'm really struggling with who the good rookies and mature age recruits are this year. All input is very much appreciated.

BACKS: GODDARD,DELEDIO, BROUGHTON, GRIMES, LAKE, HARGRAVE, CLARKE (Smedts, Morris)

MIDS: ABLETT, REDDEN, WATSON, SLOANE, HAYES, McDONALD (Neale, Magner)

RUCKS: MINSON, HALE (Giles, Redden)

FWD: FRANKLIN, FYFE, MARTIN, BALLANTYNE, DANGERFIELD, PORPS, D. SMITH (Hall, Dell'Olio)

[Titan Tim]

Backline, swap Bugg for Smedts & I'd lean towards Waters rather than Grimes

Ballantyne is my only query in the fwd line

Here's my last thought. Who will score more:

Minson & Sloane (who u have or)

Cox/Mumford & the best player you can get for the left over $$

Jst some things to think about. Just my opinion

[Alka]

Far too many midpricers. If they don't all fire, along with your rookies, you're going to be in trouble for upgrades.

I'd downgrade one of Lake or Grimes, and one of Ballantyne or Danger, and one of Sloane or Hayes (I really don't think much of Hayes tbh, average of 90 maybe) and use the extra for an actual premium - this could help your very weak ruck department immensely.

[jamez_1983]

I agree too many mid pricers.
i would get rid of 2 of hargrave/lake/clarke and bring in one more prem and two rookies (darley/bugg/ellis)
SLoane and hayes out for premium and rookie
minson and hale are risky pods but could pay off
i dont like ballantyne/porps. i would up one of them to a prem and bring in another rookie.
Hall and dell'olio probs wont play, consider pfieffer/a kennedy/tomlinson(to give you def/fwd swing)