Rookie or Mid price ruckman?

[its me lads]

wondering if its better to have 1 premo 1 mid price so heres a poll.

[Holz]

im starting both giles and hmac but if i had to choose hmac

[jfitty]

At the moment I'm looking at 1 premium and 1 mid priced (Cox & HMac) ruck setup. I keep toying with the 3 rookies and just can see it failing to easy, not a lot to fall back on if it doesn't work out. At least having HMac/Maric/Kruezer as a second ruck you can expect solid-ish scores and not stress about upgrading them as soon

[oldshepp]

Maric has burnt me before as a mid-pricer with the Crows but his pre-season form with his new club can't really be faulted.

JS is excellent as opposed to starting a rookie ruckmen too

[yorgis]

gotta go premo and mid and 2 rooks. i have a feeling the rooks are going to be very inconsistent. and every week

we'll be wondering which 1 to play on the ground,and inevitably, it will be the wrong one. the benchy will score more

[T Dog]

Jamar 24 hit outs Redden 8 at half time tonight

[its me lads]

jamar 45 hit outs. david hale half way through q3 100 points

[BC2010]

Going with Cox and Giles, with Redden and Rowe (for DP only) on the bench.

Have Hale as my F6, and will swap him with Rowe if required. 

[Master Q]

Best rookie out of those is probably Giles... Not just scoring wise.

And for Mid-Pricers Kruezer > Maric...

[fertalong]

I'm going with Hmac as my 2nd. Hopefully straight swap for premium around bye time.

[nostradamus]

l am really unsure which way to go here.....l did have the 1 premo 3 rook setup, but have now got a 2/2 set up.

......but am going to sit down and work out some projected figures for the 2 set ups l mentioned as well as the
1 premo 1 mid-price 2 rook option.......taking into account the upgrades any extra money allows