need a smart supercoachers opininion

[eagles_h]

Which is best...

Swan, Sidebottom and magner
or
Selwood, M Robinson and C Smith

And

L Hayes or A gaff, or C masten or rookie for 4th mid

[freezer]

Not a fan of any of those combinations sorry... do think there are some better possibilities avaialble.

Option 1 - Sidebottom over priced, Magner might miss a game or two (still needs to be upgraded from rookie list)

Option 2 -Robinson has been injured

Option 3 - Gaff & Masten too inconsistent

Cheers

[Footyrulz]

get a rookie for your 4th mid. if that gives u enough cash then get the second pption but upgrade robinson.

if u dont have the cash then number 1.