rate for a rate?

[gotheroos!]

goddard scotland broughton adcock lake ellis smedts (bugg darley)
ablett boyd selwood watson stevens pfeiffer (gibson miles)
mumford redden (giles stephenson)
franklin goodes pavlich martin dangerfield d.smith kerridge (hall couch)

thoughts? thx! only 5k left.

[Dylbags]

Backs - good, may be better options than Adcock but he may become a good unique, Smedts job security may be questionable too
Mids - solid
Rucks 1/3 could be risky but also may pay off
Fwd - safe and sound

9/10
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,51003.0.html

[johnnytheboy1]

Backs  I like the inclusion of Adcock in your team may give you that extra advantage, Darley on the Field instead of Smedts.
Mids Looks Great If Stevens dosen't get into the starting team go with Clifton  I see you have Pfeiffer there probably due to him being a DPP.
Rucks: Many people will have either Redden or Giles as second Ruck just need to make sure redden is in the team.
Fwds: Very Good Depth like it alot.

Overall  Your team is shaping out well it has enough premiums to be competitive its not the best side i  hav seen  but it is good enough.  8/10

Rate My Team
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50052.0.html

[Squalidly Pristine]

goddard scotland broughton adcock lake ellis smedts (bugg darley)
ablett boyd selwood watson stevens pfeiffer (gibson miles)
mumford redden (giles stephenson)
franklin goodes pavlich martin dangerfield d.smith kerridge (hall couch)

thoughts? thx! only 5k left.

Backs: again adcock is a risk, has burned many in the past but he is a good risk at 4th position. if he does get injured you can always downgrade to an up and coming conca or hargrave

Mids: cant see watson in the top 15 mids at seasons end. fantastic player but just not quite there when it comes to sc. will get tagged. might suggest a priddis or murphy instead. i like the idea of 4 guns and 2 rookies and youve included a DPP in pfeiffer so thats good. if those rookies perform you can see an upgrade to a prem in no time.

Rucks: you must have cox mate. youll be kicking yourself when he scores the big 140s and youll be spending the whole year chasing him. but i also have the 1+3 strategy.

Forwards: perfect. maybe go for a semi prem instead of goodes and pick goodesy up mid season he always seems to have a slow start and dominate at the end of the season.

Overall: i like the idea of using almost every cent. 24 trades go quickly especially with the odd injury and bye weeks so good idea to have a solid 10 mil team from round 1.

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,51050.0.html
thanks

[mpollock]

Excellent team ... everyone has to sacrifice 1 player either forward, back, mid or ruck.
You went with the ruck sacrifice ... huge risk but gives you goodes in your team basically.

I am debating the same ... Hale/McIntosh/Kruizer etc and Porps up forward v Rookie ruck and Goodes.
The other approach is to get both Hargrave and Lake for example to save in the backline ...

9/10 ... could swap things around but like all of us you will still have a weakness somewhere for 1 position.

[felsty]

goddard scotland broughton adcock lake ellis smedts (bugg darley)
ablett boyd selwood watson stevens pfeiffer (gibson miles)
mumford redden (giles stephenson)
franklin goodes pavlich martin dangerfield d.smith kerridge (hall couch)

thoughts? thx! only 5k left.

really strong side! backs are good although broughton is a rollercoaster ride. he tempts me with his ps though! adcock great pick! solid midfield also.. although watson is quite injury prone. rucks i dont like. i think you need cox if going the three rookie structure. then again i wouldnt even go the 3 rookie structure after reddens performance last night. forward line is great!
all up its a very strong side - i just think you need to fix up rucks at the expense of watson..
rate mine? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50900.30.html

[salce]

strong side mate.

Backs - Like the picks of broughton and adcock. I always go with broughton.

Mids - Very strong midfield. Watson will do wonders for you

Rucks - I'm not sure about the 1/3 ruck strategy people are going for, risky.

Fwds - Very similar structure to mine. Loving it!

9/10

rate mine? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,51102.0.html

[ando_10]

goddard scotland broughton adcock lake ellis smedts (bugg darley)
ablett boyd selwood watson stevens pfeiffer (gibson miles)
mumford redden (giles stephenson)
franklin goodes pavlich martin dangerfield d.smith kerridge (hall couch)

thoughts? thx! only 5k left.

B: i dont mind it. im still unsure on broughton at this point. dont know where he will end up playing apart from that nice :)
M: strong maybe a little to strong but still great never the less.
R: Exactly the same as mine :)
F:swap pav for fyfe?? then i think thats a winner :D

8.5/10 for mine

heres mine http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50984.0.html