easy fyfe or chappy

[m-ry]

pretty easy one for you's all. i have fyfe in my team but is he 100% and i hear chappy is having a great pre season. choose one

[bindas123]

go with the younger bloke mate

[no eye deer]

I think the poll results speak for themselves!

[nichsa673]

And geelong will rotate players a lot. aim for an upgrade target after byes

[m-ry]

Bahaha who was the chump that went chappy 28-1 land slide

[Ziplock]

chapman. Fyfe has had off season injury concerns etc. while chapman had an interrupted 2011 to quote 'my worst season ever' and still averaged 100. Chappy has shown he can average 115+, which Fyfe hasn't.

go for the underpriced proven performer :P

[brownmans muffins]

I've got both to go with Buddy, Dusty and Goodes. Rookies everywhere else in every single position.

[sj9177]

"Bahaha who was the chump that went chappy 28-1 land slide"

me - I've had Fyfe last two years (by dumb ass luck i picked him as a rookie in my starting side), and am seriously contemplating him this year, but the difference is hes 580k this year as apposed to 100k ish first year and 300k ish last year.

Who knows what Lyon will do to the midfield at Freo, whereas i suspect Geelongs setup in set