what do you think?

[t-rent]

DEF: Goddard, Shaw, Birchalll, Broughton, Hargrave, Ellis, Darley (Smedts, Bugg)

MID: Pendlebury, Boyd, Ablett, Redden, Clifton, Shiel (McDonald, Magner)

RUCK: Jacobs, Kruezer (Giles, Redden)

FWD: Franklin, Fyfe, Martin, Sidebottom, Dangerfield, Smith, Pfieffer (Cameron, Kerridge)

$58k in the bank

[its me lads]

DEF: Nothing to fault here.

MID: Nothing to fault here.

RUCK: Something to fault here. I wouldn't be getting Kruezer. Not a good enough pick yet, a rookie would be better or maybe even Hmac who i wouldn't recommend but he is an option.

FWD: Nothing to fault here.

What i would do is get rid of Kruezer and get a rookie like the big O and then upgrade a rookie from defense and get Brian Lake or Upgrade a forward Rookie and get Porplyzia who will only set you back 200k and Lake will only cost you 250k. Thats just my opinion.

Overall 9/10. I really like your team, good stuff.

[t-rent]

thanks dude!

but I dunno about the whole 3 rookie ruck setup :/ I think kruezer could have a good year cos he will get good time in ruck and go forward and kick goals but what you said is something to think about!

[its me lads]

No Problem

I feel your concern about the 3 rookie ruck, i didn't have it to start with but now i do and I'm still not sold on it. If you think Kruezer is a chance to have a good season then go for it. Hard to argue with a gut feeling. 8)

[t-rent]

yeah but also you know how you told me to get lake or porps? I have both hargrave and danger in FWD and DEF and dont really wanna have 2 of the same if you know what I mean? I was thinking waters.....but not really sure. your thoughts?

[its me lads]

all about personal preference i guess. I have both Lake and Hargrave in defense and Porps and Danger in forward. I'm  not a fan of Waters to be honest, too injury prone but like i said, personal preference its up to you :P I like Duffield is a good option i think but you already have Broughton in defense :S. I suppose Mackie or Gram could also be an option but i'm not too keen on either.