Miles = Smiles

[Cicjose]

got to go miles if named

[Justin Bieber]

Shiel = Supercoach
Miles = Dreamteam

How do you know that? How can Shiel be* SC?

whatlez, just purely based on the 2011 averages in NEAFL below. i don't have either player but if Dylan Shiels is named in round 1 i'll lock him in both my DT and SC team. hope this helps  :)


Name   Position    Games    DT Avg.    Games 100+    High Score    Low Score
Anthony Miles Mid14           103                8                               142         41
Dylan Shiel   Mid   10            96                6                               129         37


Name   Position   Games        SC Avg.      Games 100+   High Score   Low Score
Dylan Shiel   Mid   10                 124             9                 174       59
Anthony MilesMid   14                119           8                 181       83

Well Shiel's lowest score in SC is way lower than Miles.

Also how could Miles have a SC of 83, but DT of 41?

[Ziplock]

minimal disposals with maximum efficiency? Kicked a goal when they were behind?

[Justin Bieber]

But 41 turns into 83? How often does that happen

[Ziplock]

a match winning goal would do it.

[Justin Bieber]

Is that how SC works? You get more points if you kick a goal when your behind?

[Spite]

Is that how SC works? You get more points if you kick a goal when your behind?

Yes. As long as it is not "junk time" which is when goals aren't worth as much. A winning goal can bump a players score amazingly high. I think cyril one game got 15 possessions, 12 score assists and got like 130+ SC for something like 60-70 DT points.

[Ziplock]

not necessarily spite, didn't like brown get something ridiculous like 110 point or something a few years back after taking the mark in the dying seconds, the siren going, taking the shot and scoring to win by 1?

[Insider out]

My boy Milesy looked pretty good today!

[Windigo]

Just dominance mate.  ;)

GWS have a better talent pool than GC IMO.

[Zombie2.5]

Just dominance mate.  ;)

GWS have a better talent pool than GC IMO.
+1

If you look back to last year most of the best rookies were not from GC. I now only have 3 GWS rookies.

I'd argue that GWS have done a much better job at recruiting than GC. Wouldn't surprise me if half of the top ten best performing rookies in 2012 come from there. Having said that, I've only got one more GWS rook than you right now.

+1
Lock in Giles & Miles
Don't lock in Shiel and Neale :P

[D.Zanetti]

Just dominance mate.  ;)

GWS have a better talent pool than GC IMO.

agreed, GC focused on buying talent for now when we all know they won't win a premiership within 3-4 years, where GWS have used it for future players IMO