Which Mid Pricer is less risky?

[tigers123]

They will be my fifth defender or my fifth forward

[Justin Bieber]

I'm thinking of getting both. I got the money to. But I voted Hargrave in this instance.

[Dudge]

Porps looked very good last night. I'm so tempted but them shoulders still scare the b-geebuzz out of me. Mind u could , and i say COULD be a great pick-up for his price. So far Hargrave has looked impressive aswell. Some very tough decisions coming up me thinks

[Colliwobblers]

had hargrave for ages, voted him, but traded in porps last night.... for now

[Dudge]

As i said Colli, he looked very good last night, but are u also worried that his shoulders will hold up. I realise we must risk it for the biscuit, but i dont know if i could handle slapping myself  if things go pear shape, when i know all the cons about him . What im trying to figure out would it be safer with a high profile rook.