Risk??? HAVE A GEEZ and CRITISISE!!!!!!!!!

[MartyNadort]

BACKLINE = Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, Shaw, Clarke, Lake, Ellis (Bugg, Wilkes)

MIDS = GAJ, Swan, J.Selwood, Caddy, C.Smith, L.Brown (McDonald, Magner)

RUCKS = Mummy, Krezuer (Stephenson, Giles, Redden????)

FORWARDS = Franklin, Goodes, Martin, Cloke, Porps, Pfeiffer, Treloar (Saad, Dickson)

SALARY = $181,300

Are my rookies alright???
Not sure on risk of Lake + Clarke in backline??
And should I just get rid of Krezuer and leave Redden in the starting 22?

[PICCOLLO]

Rookies have 2 elements: scoring potential and job security.
Bad scoring potential: wilkes
Poor js: clay smith, brown. Pfieffer.

I like ur remaining salary.  120k should be enough tho.
Redden over stephensen.
Caddy might fit ur bye strategy but clifton will save you big $$$$
The rest good.  Krez isnt my style - redden a gun.

[MartyNadort]

Is their anyone you think I should replace Krezuer for??????

[tor01doc]

Clarke out for a rookie.

Upgrade Kreuzer to anyone - maybe Jacobs.

Quite like Caddy - maybe a really good sub even at the end of the year.

Cloke?? Big KPP's are on the nose the way they play now. Maybe Sidebottom / Danger / Gray?

Spend a little money Scrooge! ;D

[TheMailman]

Is their anyone you think I should replace Krezuer for??????

You don't need to.

Unless someone gives reasons and facts over why you shouldn't pick someone, just keep them.

For example I won't bring Leunburger to replace Jacobs because nobody could give any strong reasons

Kreuzer is fine

[tor01doc]

True, TheMailman.

Don't mind Kreuzer too much at R2. He was asking though.

Side looks pretty good if he can fire.

[MartyNadort]

The new and improved side!!!!

BACKLINE = Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, Shaw, Lake, Guthrie, Ellis (Bugg, Darley)

MIDS = GAJ, Swan, J.Selwood, Wingard, Clifton, Kerridge, (McDonald, Magner)

RUCKS = Mummy, Luenberger (Stephenson, Giles)

FORWARDS = Franklin, Goodes, Martin, Fyfe, Porps, D.Smith, T.Hill  (Saad, Couch)

SALARY = $1,500

[MartyNadort]

Come on lads need some help?!

[tor01doc]

Hello.

Very balanced now.

Rookies are anyone's guess.

Like Guthrie and Lake - slightly more pricey but should get games and one might even become a good D6/7 for the season.

Wingard is popular but expensive.

Magner's finger is a concern and watch as he might be better as a later in the year pick up.

Rucks are excellent although Redden looks the goods compared to Stephenson.

13 premiums seems a good number.

Nice.

[MartyNadort]

Thanks mate.. I have changed Stephenson to Redden after reading the Herald haha

[tor01doc]

One does not read the Herald, one merely looks at the pictures.

[MartyNadort]

Is their any rookies that are decent in the midfield.. Im a bit shaky on Magner as the dislocation may be a trouble for him in early stages of the 2012 season?

[felsty]

The new and improved side!!!!

BACKLINE = Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, Shaw, Lake, Guthrie, Ellis (Bugg, Darley)
MIDS = GAJ, Swan, J.Selwood, Wingard, Clifton, Kerridge, (McDonald, Magner)
RUCKS = Mummy, Luenberger (Stephenson, Giles)
FORWARDS = Franklin, Goodes, Martin, Fyfe, Porps, D.Smith, T.Hill  (Saad, Couch)

SALARY = $1,500

Backs are great although not a fan of broughton.. could save some money on guthrie as he will just be a cash cow anyway
Mids are very solid, even the rookies.. great picks!
Love MY rucks!
Forwards are great again... almost my forward line ;) dont know the js on hill
all in all a 9/10 really good team!

[MartyNadort]

Who do you think is a better pick for Broughton?? I'm not entirely sold on Adcock..
Your rucks were the same as mine when i looked at yours haha coincidence?
Yeah im not sold on Hill either, not sure who would be a good pick in the fward lin????

[tor01doc]

Kerridge from Adelaide DPP M/F?

Pity Bock is such a cokhead.

Broughton should be fine - team will go well this year and he'll score for you most weeks.

Enright probably a year late.

Shaw is over at Bock's having a card night.