Rate my team, and I'll rate yours

[Griffo35]

As the title says, rate my team and I'll rate yours, I thought it was a good way for everyone to get some feedback and criticism.
Thanks in advance.

[the captain]

Move Clarke and McIntosh onto your field.

Upgrade Heppell, downgrade Gunthrie.

Get someone cheaper for Conlgilo (Maybe Sam Gibson) and Stevens, then upgrade Barlow.

[Griffo35]

Thanks, I've uploaded the wrong picture, obviously they'll be on my field Round 1.
I don't really like the selection of defensive premiums, can't really see any standouts to upgrade to?

[the captain]

You're best choice is probably Scotland if you can afford him.

[tor01doc]

Reckon Guthrie will be a ripper. If he gets as many games as Clarke, he'll be in my team. Watch teams round 1.

Barlow a risk. If he is sore as they say, then vest?

Coniglio had better be a gun at his price. Maybe save $80K and get a cheaper rookie and upgrade Barlow to say Shuey.

Best of..

[nicw98]

Defence : Pretty good, maybe downgrade Marty Clarke to Spurr or Darley with the cash upgrade Heppell, I think Guthrie will be great if he gets games.

Midfield : Well balanced maybe change McDonald to Neale, Tom Mitchell or Gibson. Barlow a bit of a risk maybe downgrade Coniglio to Wingard, Neale etc, then upgrade Barlow.

Ruck : Like your ruck choices, I think HaMac will do good this year.

Forward  : Forwards are great maybe change Goodes to another premium because he is getting a bit old and change Pav to Fyfe.

Overall : I think this is a really good and well balanced team 8.5/10, and next time show the salary cap because it makes it a lot easier to rate.

[felsty]

B: solid as heppell will do good.. I would downgrade Clarke and upgrade Guthrie to a lake or Hargrave!
M: Barlow huge risk. His leg seems to still hamper him ala Nathan Brown.. I would stay completely away and agree with the downgrade calls for coniglio. Can get players to score like him for a cheaper price..
R: perfect. Love the h.mac pick!
F: keep goodes! Absolute gun! Superb line but yeah get fyfey in
All in all 8.749/10
Rate mine? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,49811.15.html

[Colty]

Ive not taken the time to read trough every post so I may double up on comments so I apologise

I like the team as a whole -
I like that you havnt blown your bank on the the backline, I subscribe to the theroy that prem backs always hit a much lower low price than mids which makes them easier top pick up when they do hit that low.

Barlow obviously has Q marks but I dont mind it because it could really pay off!!! I like that you have spent on Coniglio, you know the guy is gunna score and not be vested at any point, ive done the same with Wingard.

I like the Rookie prem ruck combo to.

Great team mate I recon it will go really well.

Rate mine if you can mate! Cheers

[C.Judd3Votes]

That's a really nice team. Strong all areas. top stuff  ;)