First SC Team. Please Rate

[Bigheat]

Hey

This is my first SC team for the year. What do you think? Please be harsh!

Backs    Goddard   Deledio   Shaw   Birchall   Hargraves   Clarke   Bugg   (Smedts/Darley)

Mids      Ablett   Swan   Murphy   Selwood   Clifton   Magner   (Shiel/Neale)

Rucks    Sandilands   Giles   (Stephensen/Redden)

For        Franklin   Goodes   Fyfe   Martin   Porplyzia   D.Smith   Hampton   (Weeden/Hall)

$10.5K left

[Bigheat]

Anyone?????

[felsty]

few iffy picks for mine...
clifton hasnt been going very well, giles i dont think has shown enough to have a spot on the ground, hopefully porp gets back to where he was.. all in all they are well calculated risks however i would try and get some money by downgrading porps, hargraves and get in a 2nd ruck like kruze or hmac
overall a pretty good side but
rate mine? http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,50071.0.html

[tor01doc]

B: 3 have byes round 13. But fine otherwise. I like Hargraves if you think he'll return to some kind of steady form.
M: Too strong if that's possible. I say that because you've obviously taken strength from another line to stock up here - eg rucks
R: Weak here but a lot adopting this 1/3 strategy with a view to trading up later. I think trades are worth more thancash when the finals come so I'll be saving trades.
F: Like this lot.

Well done for a virgin.

[fever]

i like it man. i think the 1-3 starting ruck combo can work.

i would swap one of clarke/hargrave for an ellis type though, if for nothing else than the cash.