Player X vs Player Y thread

[My Chumps]

Broughton > Enright

Second one's tough...
Swallow > Rockliff > Boyd > Priddis > Thompson

Swallow, Rocky and Boyd are all pretty even IMO though.

As you can see by this poll which I set up.  Still none the wiser,

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,49300.0.html

Wow, talk about tight...
I think Boyd is the most conservative option, but Rockliff and Swallow have a greater upside as they're youngish players in improving teams.

[oconnell]

here is a tough one, swanny vs pendles??

[luke_dicko]

pendles over swanny, bit pricey but very safe and very consistent.

K lucas vs C Wingard

[MC]

Easily Pendles over Swan.
Wingard over Lucas - JS

Tough one for my team:

Pendles/Luenberger  VS  Thompson/Cox

[reesbr]

Pendles and leuy.

Heath shaw and mcintosh vs Mumford and Hargrave??

[peterkip]

Tough one leaning towards Shaw/McIntosh there

Buddy v Goodes v Fyfe v Pav?

[Victorius Secret]

player a or player b?

[Noz]

Buddy than Goodes than Fyfe than Pav
Jarryn Geary vs Tom Simpkin vs Jayden Pitt

[Jay]

Buddy than Goodes than Fyfe than Pav
Jarryn Geary vs Tom Simpkin vs Jayden Pitt

none...all spuds

[Noz]

Buddy than Goodes than Fyfe than Pav
Jarryn Geary vs Tom Simpkin vs Jayden Pitt

none...all spuds

Well there not

[TheMailman]

Geary > Pitt > Simpkin