Unique Mid Options

Started by Madsnake, March 06, 2012, 11:15:23 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which of these combinations will score higher all year round?

J.Kelly and J.Bartel
J.Kelly and L.Ball
L.Ball and J.Bartel
None of the above

Madsnake

Trying to figure out which unique option in the mids, really keen on Kelly this year as he will be a very unique pick but do you think 2 premo Geelong players is too many?
Who will cop the Geelong midfield tags this year?

ubeaut

Out of those combos the two Cats. Bartel has the most proven SC potential. Will be unique cause most peolpe would have Selwood. But that is cause Selwood is the most likely to be top Mid scorer from Geelong. Be careful with going unique for the sake of unique, its no good if they don't score well enough. Have you considered Watson, Montagna, or Priddis?

ubeaut

Sorry forgot this was DT. My bad. Forget Watson then and Stanton instead.

Chelskiman

Ball and Bartel for me.  Ball is a beast of a player, is a handy goal kicker too. 

Madsnake

they don't fit my bye structure.
Unique is the only way to win this damn thing.
As for kelly he is a very consistent player and is in for a big year.

Holz

Quote from: Madsnake on March 06, 2012, 11:55:55 PM
they don't fit my bye structure.
Unique is the only way to win this damn thing.
As for kelly he is a very consistent player and is in for a big year.

typically going unique in the mid is not the way to win overall, sure there have been good picks like redden and rocky but they are emerging players not established guys like bartel and kelly. In the mids you really need to have the big premiums, and finding a few breakout guys helps. For example something like Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Ziebell.

Again there are different ways of winning but i dont think going unique for the sake of unique is going to do you any help.

Grannyboy

Was that a trick question? How can you answer none of the above when you're asked which combination will score more? Obvisously one of them has to.  :o Ball and Bartel are proven magnets, and for a Brownlow winner Bartel sure is cheap this year, not to mention his 143 last week.