NDS or Selwood to start the year

Started by sj9177, March 01, 2012, 01:00:44 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

also have Boyd, Swan and GAJ

NDS
7 (23.3%)
Selwood
23 (76.7%)

Total Members Voted: 1

sj9177

Hey Guys

Selwood is obviously cheaper due to the injury at the start of last year, and NDS is predicted to drop a bit

Assuming both will be in the side by mid year who would you guys start with?

Capper

coin toss, i am going Jelwood just because of the bye structure

Droll_1985

Selwood on the basis that he is still on the improve and has now got the captaincy and will be ruthless and at times unstoppable, reckon he will be this years Scott Pendelbury if you ask me and could easily jump into the 125+ average bracket

Dal Santo is consistent and safe around the 110 - 115 mark but could not see him improving on last years output, plus new coach and game plan could come into play

Both as safe as one another but i would take Selwood for the improvement/captaincy factor

Swallow12

Selwood, Dal Santo is more of an upgrade target

4INAROW

u answered your own question, cant split them for talent, but...1 is underpriced and the other predicted to drop, the smart bet would be to get jelwood and grab nds [if] and when he drops.

burner11

Selwood, 43k cheaper with same output, frees up cash for other players ;-)

fever


sj9177

As always you guys have delivered, thanks as always.

Colliwobblers

Jelwood for reasons stated above, plus the unknown effect of the return of Lenny, could be good for NDS scoring or Bad or nothing but just pick  Jelwood and sleep easy :)

coolfugitiv0

Reasons stated above - Jelwood easily.