Murphy, Zaha and Clarke vs Caddy, Goodes and Broughton

[Nick_1069]

which combination will score more throughout the year?

if i go the first combo, murph will be my 4th mid premium, zaha will be my 5th foward and clarke will be my 5th back.

if i go with the second option, caddy will give me a 3 prem and 3 rookie mids (counting caddy as a rook), goodes will be one of my 5 prem fowards rather than zaha and brougthon would be my 5th premium back.

by my predictions, they will score right around the same -

murphy 120, zaha 100 (just), clarke 75 = 295

caddy 80, goodes 110, broughton 100 = 290

are these close to what you guys think they will get?

need some help with this one guys! would be much appreciated.

[3.votes]

id say broughton is more a 95er and goodes 100 or so. therefore the murphy group is better by 20+ points or there abouts.

[Nick_1069]

yeah, i have decided on the murphy option i think. thanks!