Joel Selwood

[hally25547]

depends on your other midfielders. I have murphy or selwood because i already have swan and pendlebury missing that round 12 game and i don't want three midfield premiums missing. In saying that, if byes are not an issue in this situation then i would go selwood

[ShaynoB]

Neither...don't like either player, go with a proper premium in Boyd/Rocky/Ablett/Swanny

U dont rate Selwood as a "proper" premium?? and for that matter rate Rocky as one??

Can I have some of what ur on!!

[Bak2Form]

Neither...don't like either player, go with a proper premium in Boyd/Rocky/Ablett/Swanny

selwoods average has increased every year he has played including last year when he missed games and also scored the 27 when he got injured in the 1st quarter. I rate him higher than rocky who has only been "proper premium" one year and not prroven

[Justin Bieber]

Jukes Murphy isn't a proven prem? Didn't he come third overall last year?

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

Neither...don't like either player, go with a proper premium in Boyd/Rocky/Ablett/Swanny

selwoods average has increased every year he has played including last year when he missed games and also scored the 27 when he got injured in the 1st quarter. I rate him higher than rocky who has only been "proper premium" one year and not prroven

the only reason why I'm not picking rocky this year. if he
averages 105+ this year he's a def lock next year.

[Memphistopheles]

Both are ripping picks.

Like others have said it depends on the rest of your team.

Personally I will take Selwood from the start, but Murphy could still be in my team by the end of the season as an upgrade.

[elephants]

I hahve Murphy over Selwood but I am trying to get in both by playing Selwood over Pendles :)

[stew42]

Selwood's a proven legend who wins his own ball. His average has increased every year since his debut.
Quite similar with Murphy also.
It's a hard decision to make, but there aren't that many big consequences, coz you can be fairly sure that all will do well...

[elephants]

True, a premium is a premium and they won't be averaging less than 110 you wouldn't have thought...