Beams, Cloke or Sidebottom

[underdog11]

i have cloke, but its been a commonly asked question throughout the pre-season, which one/two will you have

[Windigo]

I have Sidebottom. Most likely to up the average IMO.

[n4cr123]

Sidebottom for sure!

[underdog11]

I am really surprised so far, why is everyone off cloke

[Windigo]

I am really surprised so far, why is everyone off cloke

I'd love to have him. But SideBum is cheaper, a DPP and arguably more upside.

But Cloke is a good unique choice. Why not squeeze in both!  :P

[Football Factory]

Sidebum

[Jukes]

I got Beamsy and Sidey.

[big davo]

I only got beamsy

[4INAROW]

sidey and cloke for me.

[underdog11]

clokes being well over looked, IMO, the best of the three

[nostradamus]

There are good reasons to select any of them

Cloke is a monster, and can rip teams to pieces

Beams had a fantasic season lasy year

Sidebum is earmarked for alot more mid action this year

.....out of the 3 l like the upside in Sidebum the best

[Mozza3]

clokes being well over looked, IMO, the best of the three

I agree Underdog. He showed signs in the 2nd half of last year that he can be nearly unstoppable. still only 24 I think, the only way is up.

[Colliwobblers]

sidebottom will score close to the same as beams and croak and cost you significantly less, for consistancy beams, for overall high avg croak, for potential and value sidebottom

[Bones Bombers]

clokes being well over looked, IMO, the best of the three

Problem is Cloke is a key position forward, and there are a number of good midfield/forwards this year.
Players running through the midfield will almost always score more.
There have been key position forwards who have scored well like Cloke last year and then scored relatively poorly the next year.
Without knowing the numbers I would say NRoo and JRoo scored well in 2010 and not so well in 2011.
Obviously Cloke may come out and kill it this year but I'd rather have mid/forwards.