draft #8384 Rate my team!!!

[saintsman12]

my forward line in my perspective is a tad risky but please give me feedback or advice on who to swap~!!

[Ringo]

Gave a rating 7.
Def: If Grimes is a keeper then you have 3 prems with byes in Round 12.
Mids: Sound
Rucks: Not a fan of Prem and 3 rooks but enough threads on that for you to make your mind up.  Concern is that Giles may not be initial 1st Ruck at Sydney if Nab cup is a guide so then you are relying on Stephenson or Rowe to step up. As I say just personal.
Forwards: IMO risk with Martin at F3 with Tigers hard early draw. Happy to see as F4 though.