Please Rate My Team :)

Dnelson1991 · February 16, 2012, 01:45:29 PM

BACKS : Goddard , Grimes , Lake , Hargrave , Clarke , Drummond , B. Ellis SUBS Smedts , L.Brown
MIDS : G. Ablett , J. Selwood , M.Murphy , Barlow , Hayes , Moribito SUBS Mc Donald , T.Mitchell
RUCKS : Mc Intosh , Kreuzer SUBS Giles , Stephensen
FORWARDS : Fyfe , Martin , Sidebottom , J.Brown , Zaharakis , Dangerfield , Porplyzia SUBS Zorko , Dickson

Would love feedback on what you guys think :) i think it is solid but may need some changing.

Ltv123 · February 16, 2012, 02:16:56 PM

Pretty solid team, there is a lot to like here. Be careful of Morabito though i have heard is isn't tracking too well and is not training with the main group. You have taken quite a few risks on players coming back from injury which could pay off but it could hurt you if multiple players have recurrences. Drummond Grimes and Porpoise in particular are always huge injury risks and having all three might really hurt you if they are unlucky with injuries again.

Ringo · February 16, 2012, 06:56:10 PM

I think you have gone far to heavy in the mids.
Defence is weak with having Grimes and Lake at D2 and D3.
Mids: Super but possibly over strong at expense of defence,
Rucks: Risk here with 2 mid price and 2 rookies
Forwrads; Sound

Not sure of how much cash you have but you need to look at getting a super prem in defence Delidio, Scotland, Birchall etc.
Would also look at upgrading one of the rucks to a prem
Rate 7/10.

fever · February 16, 2012, 06:59:29 PM

agree with ringo on all fronts. you need another prem def ruck and fwd

Dnelson1991 · February 16, 2012, 10:53:46 PM

Thanks for the feedback guys , will try to take your advice and update my team :)

Dnelson1991 · February 17, 2012, 09:55:57 PM

alright made some changes - Lids in the back line for Drummond
- Caddy in the mid for Barlow
- Mumford for Kreuzer
- Dangerfield for Rohan

Thoughts? i don't know on caddy and also if i should keep Barlow and not Hayes and to get rid of McIntosh and leave kruezer and Mumford.

Also thoughts on Rohan

Dnelson1991 · February 19, 2012, 06:24:10 PM

OK , Here is my updated team let me know if it looks better :)

Backs - Goddard , Birchall , Heppell , Grimes , Hargrave , Clarke , Ellis SUBS Smedts , L.Brown
Mids - Ablett , Murphy , Selwood , Fyfe , Hayes , Mc Donald SUBS Hampton , T.Mitchell
Rucks - Kreuzer , McIntosh SUBS Oren , Giles
Forwards - Franklin , Martin , Zaharakis , Sidebottom , Rohan , Porplyzia , Pfeiffer SUBS Zorko , Treloar

Don't know if i should put Franklin to Rioli and then change Birchall for Lids or scottland?

Also i know the rucks are a bit weak but may take a risk , Also thoughts on Rohan??

Cheers :)