Surely at least an 8.5/10!!! top 1% player, will rate yours

Droll_1985 · February 16, 2012, 03:19:58 PM

Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, J Grimes, M Clarke, B Ellis, T Mohr (S Morris, L Brown (ade) )

Mids: Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Barlow, Shiel, T Mitchell (J Mcdonald, T Couch)

Rucks: Cox, Leuenberger (O Stephenson, J Giles)

Forward: Franklin, Pavlich, D Martin, N Roo, J Brown, D Zorko, B Smedts (J Cameron, S Rowe)

Pending nab cup bench and on field rookies etc think this is a good balance

ben_020285 · February 16, 2012, 07:02:48 PM

Very nice structured team. I would just make a few player changes.

BACKS: I'm not sold on Broughton just yet, I think he would be a better upgrade target as it's unknown how he will be played this year plus Dockers have a tough early draw. Grimes is another player who is a better upgrade target. If his body is right halfway through the season then I reckon he is worth a punt. Also, the Dees play all 8 of last years finalists during first 10 rounds. Shaw and Heppell would be 2 good additions for Broughton and Grimes.

MIDS: Nice looking midfield. 3 prems from the same bye round (round 12) in the mids is a bit risky but just make sure that you don't have 3 players from the round 12 byes on any other lines come round 12 or you will get multiple donuts.

RUCKS: Cox and Leuenberger share the same bye during round 11. You will need to swap one of them considering you have Giles on the bench who also has the round 11 bye. I would swap Cox to save some cash for your backline changes. McEvoy is a good replacement as you do not have a ruckman from the round 13 byes yet.

FWDS: You have 3 prems from round 13 in your fwd line which is ok but once again just make sure that you don't have 3 players on any other lines come round 13. Having both N Roo and Brown is a bit risky too. I would consider Zaharakis for N Roo both for team balance and less risk.

8/10

SonsOfZeus · February 16, 2012, 11:43:56 PM

Quote from: ben_020285 on February 16, 2012, 07:02:48 PM
Very nice structured team. I would just make a few player changes.

BACKS: I'm not sold on Broughton just yet, I think he would be a better upgrade target as it's unknown how he will be played this year plus Dockers have a tough early draw. Grimes is another player who is a better upgrade target. If his body is right halfway through the season then I reckon he is worth a punt. Also, the Dees play all 8 of last years finalists during first 10 rounds. Shaw and Heppell would be 2 good additions for Broughton and Grimes.

MIDS: Nice looking midfield. 3 prems from the same bye round (round 12) in the mids is a bit risky but just make sure that you don't have 3 players from the round 12 byes on any other lines come round 12 or you will get multiple donuts.

RUCKS: Cox and Leuenberger share the same bye during round 11. You will need to swap one of them considering you have Giles on the bench who also has the round 11 bye. I would swap Cox to save some cash for your backline changes. McEvoy is a good replacement as you do not have a ruckman from the round 13 byes yet.

FWDS: You have 3 prems from round 13 in your fwd line which is ok but once again just make sure that you don't have 3 players on any other lines come round 13. Having both N Roo and Brown is a bit risky too. I would consider Zaharakis for N Roo both for team balance and less risk.

8/10

barlow isnt a prem atm and stay cxlear of grimes

8.51/10

jamesalex · February 17, 2012, 05:30:34 PM

Solid but very stock-standard, like my team.

8.5/10.

MC · February 17, 2012, 09:41:36 PM

As already mentioned - 3 rucks with the same bye is going to be an issue.
Looks like a pretty good team - at least until after the NAB cup and a few mid pricers are massively hyped up ;)

If you could rate mine that would be sweet. Cheers
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,48491.0.html

Jay · February 17, 2012, 09:52:23 PM

Good team...fairly stock-standard but that doesnt matter, should score well. 8.75/10

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,48411.0.html

Rate mine thanks

Madmax75 · February 18, 2012, 12:40:19 PM

Have to agree with above comments. Bit too much risk with Grimes and Roo and Brown. The whole forward structure is something that I'm struggling with though atm. If you don't go n Roo or props as 5th forward which forward should he put in? Start with 3 rookies? The rest of your team I like with good premium choices apart from the bye problems. Good luck and I'd give you 8.5/10
Rate mine please:
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,48528.0.html

Colliwobblers · February 18, 2012, 12:53:20 PM

i give it 8/10 fair bit of risk involved and if grimes doesnt work nroo or brown dont or barlow doesnt you really only have 3 proven premiums per line. Although that's a bit harsh on the fwd line which is strong enough.

Ruck is extremely solid, premiums you do have are all strong picks, rooks don't matter yet.

Solid side any cash left?

Here is mine so you can rip into it :) http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,45491.0.html