Ellis or Morris?

[Jake8]

Which rookie defender should I get?

[ben_020285]

Too hard to tell at this stage. Just put one of them in at the moment. Follow them both during NAB cup and then choose the better performer of the 2 ensuring that they play round 1 of the home and away season!

[JimMundy93]

Is go Morris just because he has more of an afl ready body

[itchytradefinger]

Yeah I reckon you always go the player with the more mature body.

Maybe the pre season will make things easier. Will be interesting to see whether they both get selected round one.

[jabroni]

morris has an afl ready body but looks to get the shutdown role while ellis and his sharp kicking looks to have a less accountable role but obviously wait till later nab cup stages

[ando_10]

ellis may score higher where morris may be a shut down player.

[jasonweare]

Think I read somewhere Ellis was practicing his kicking in as well.

[Cruiseon]

I'm thinking both.

[itchytradefinger]

Think I read somewhere Ellis was practicing his kicking in as well.

Good for SC, completely useless for DT.

[roti]

ellis is a gun

[newfreofan]

Both for me unless NAB cup/ round 1 teams prove otherwise

[Usman]

Morris was better at the intraclub but the club has been impressed by Ellis also. I have both but if you have to choose one Morris is just ahead.

[coolfugitiv0]

Keep in mind that one of them will most likely have the vest if they both start, while if only one of them is named, he'll probably still get the vest.

The vest! The enemy of SC.

[JamSainter]

BOTH! You can't lose, both good players, both will get game time, rise in price AND have the Round 13 bye which is all important for rookies.

[Bruce McAvaney]

morris. ellis is green vest material due to his ability to play multiple positions