set in stone V2

[cortez]

hopefully i wont be changing this team going into round 1 if tbe rookies i have chosen go well. have gone for mostly mature age rookies with the exception of  shiel, Hampton, and ellis.
Have conciously not chosen too many gws with only 3 in my team knowing how they will rotate there kids.
please leave feedback if you can and rate out of 10 thanks guys.

DEF: B. Goddard, B. Deledio, H. Shaw, G. Broughton, M. Clarke, B. Ellis, S. Morris (B. Smedts, L. Brown)
MID: G. Ablett jnr, D. Swan, J. Selwood, K. Stevens, K. Horsely, D. Shiel (B. Lee, S. Gibson)
RUC: M. Leuenberger, H. McIntosh (J. Giles, O. Stephenson)
FWD: L. Franklin, N. Fyfe, M. Pavlich, P. Chapman, C. Rioli, G. Rohan, D. Pfeiffer (C. Hampton, D. Zorko)

[cortez]

sorry for reposting. it was unable to receive replies before.

The reason i have gone for the structure i have is because i dont rate many backmen this yea that is the reason for only 4
in the mids i see plenty of great rookies and that is why i have taken only 3 prems.
Rucks i have chosen luey and hmac as one of my two mid prices hoping that he will be a sideways trade halfway tbrough the year.
And in the forwards i have gone with a very strong forward line to cover my weaker other lines. the reason i chose a forward line like this is cause i rate all 5 of tbe prems i have chosen very highly and didnt want to leave any of them out and im picking rohan  with stevens to be the biggest breakout player this year.

If anyone has an opinion on what ive just said please dont hesitate to say something.
thanks.

[sticks]

looks good, im just not keen on m clarke cant see him getting alot of game time
thats if he can break into the collingwood side and if he does i dont think
he will play a lot of games

[cortez]

I dont think anyone really knows how much game time he will get but good things are coming out of collingwood atm about him so that is good enough for me atm.

[sticks]

true, hopefully hes fit enough after his time away from the game

[cortez]

could someone give me an in depth report of my team with a rating please.

[Ringo]

Will expand on my PM for you. Not commenting on rookies as it is pirely subjective till we get a handle on them via NAB Cup.

Def: Good with question mark now over Clarke and whether he will play round 1, 3 solid prems and one near solid prem in Brougton depending on how Lyon uses him. If he brings the St Kilda type play to Freo can see Broughton becoming like Fisher.
Mids: Appreciate your reasons for 3 prems and rookie structure.  My only concern with it is expecting 3 rookies to perform each week at similar levels to a 4th prem. Strategy that may come off though.
Rucks: Sound but enough discussion around H Mac for you to make your mind up, Trust he will increase sufficiently in price prior to byes to allow your sideways trade.
Forwards: Can not fault.  Watch Rohan in NAB cup to sere whether form shown in trials continues to NAB Cup.

Overall very sound team with 8/10 rating.