Rate Me

[Scrads]

Duffield/Armstrong/Lake is way too much of a risk, the chances of all 3 coming off a very slim. Just go with one of them so that if it messes up, it isnt hard to rectify. Hawkins and Porplyzia are in the same boat, but I would stray away from them both. Porplyzia wont score much more than a normal rookie so you can save yourself some cash there, and hawkins will probably hover in the middle of DT mediocrity for a while so I would find a better option there.

[PowerMan]

Duffield/Armstrong/Lake is way too much of a risk, the chances of all 3 coming off a very slim. Just go with one of them so that if it messes up, it isnt hard to rectify. Hawkins and Porplyzia are in the same boat, but I would stray away from them both. Porplyzia wont score much more than a normal rookie so you can save yourself some cash there, and hawkins will probably hover in the middle of DT mediocrity for a while so I would find a better option there.

I reckon Duffield is less of a risk as he'll more than likely return to his half back role this season as he had to play a Midfield role last because of Freo's injury's.

Hawkins has more upside potential than risk, he's a break out contender especially considering J Pod is struggling with injury this pre-season.

[boo-yaa]

a zone defence during the season will make hawkins look very average, correct me if i'm wrong but wasn't the grand final a man on man setup?
collingwood changed their game plan for the GF and it didn't come off ?

[PowerMan]

Hows this for different looking side?

$7,100 left in the bank

D: B Goddard, H Shaw, B Deledio, S Burgoyne, P Duffield, P Davis, M Clarke, (M Buntine, C Guthrie)
M: D Swan, G Ablett, S Thompson, L Hayes, D Zorko, D Shiel, (L Brown, S Gilbert)
R: A Sandilands, J Giles, (J Redden, O Stephenson)
F: L Franklin, N Fyfe, T Cloke, D Zaharakis, N Riewoldt, D Pfeiffer, C Hampton, (B Smedts, T Walsh)