Sandys/Burger vs Cox/Jacobs

Started by tisdons, February 12, 2012, 12:54:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

tisdons

Not sure which why to go, any thoughts

JamSainter


elephants

Cox and Jacobs share the round 11 bye and Giles has it too...

I'd look at a combo involving Jacobs/McEvoy or Mummy/McEvoy or Mummy/Jacobs (mine).

mezzoculo

Honestly, the rucks are doing my head in  :-\

Windigo

Quote from: elephants on February 12, 2012, 02:10:41 PM
Cox and Jacobs share the round 11 bye and Giles has it too...

I'd look at a combo involving Jacobs/McEvoy or Mummy/McEvoy or Mummy/Jacobs (mine).

Same.

JamSainter


Crows84


Colliwobblers

sandi jacobs for me  and if sandi breaks his stupid toe mummy jacobs :)

Juddster5


elephants

Quote from: Juddster5 on February 12, 2012, 11:39:29 PM
Cox and the Hamberger for me
Assuming you have Giles your rucks will be screwed in round 11.

Justin Bieber


mezzoculo

Quote from: JamSainter on February 12, 2012, 05:38:58 PM
I have Mummy and McEvoy :D

According to the Prospectus, McEvoy got a fair slab of his Champion Data points from playing the defensive 'kick-behind-play' role. From memory (Prospectus is at home), he ranks lower in 'ruck-related' statistics (again, no Prospectus at hand) than other comparable rucks (Leuenberger, Mummy, Goldstein, Jacobs etc).

The way I read it, under a new coach who has promised a more attacking game plan then there is a good chance that his 2012 scoring won't improve on 2011 (or could go backward if he plays a less defensive game).

Mummy, OTOH, seems to tick all the boxes.

yorgis

cox, luey, jacobs, sandi, mummy, mc evoy are all great choices, just make sure they don't share the same bye

fo me, i'm taking cox and and mc evoy

tisdons

Thanks guys, heaps to pick from

Sandi has rd 12 bye and burger has rd 11

According to the Prospectus, McEvoy got a fair slab of his Champion Data points from playing the defensive 'kick-behind-play' role. From memory (Prospectus is at home), he ranks lower in 'ruck-related' statistics (again, no Prospectus at hand) than other comparable rucks (Leuenberger, Mummy, Goldstein, Jacobs etc).

The way I read it, under a new coach who has promised a more attacking game plan then there is a good chance that his 2012 scoring won't improve on 2011 (or could go backward if he plays a less defensive game).

Agree can't see him going impoving to much

Football Factory