Feedback Wanted - Rate mine and I rate yours

[JRizzle]

Trying something different this year.
More than happy to rate your team if you rate mine.

Backs - Goddard, Scotland, Deledio, Drummond, Lake, Clarke, Darley
emerg - Smedts, Morris

Mids - Pendlebury, Judd, Ablett, Barlow, Shiel, Clifton
emerg - Pfeiffer,L. Brown
 
Ruck - Cox, Goldstein
emerg - Giles, Rowe

Forwards - Franklin, S. Johnson, Pavlich, Porplyzia, Saad, Adams, Hampton
emerg - Zorko, Couch

$84.3k

Would like more in the forward line. Options in ruck with a potential to move goldstein for a cheaper ruck to enhance forward line. Not convinced with Drummond either.

Initial thoughts before NAB?

[felsty]

Yeah bit of a risk on porp and drummond but they both will play round 1 so stick to your guns!
lake hasnt got out of rehab group yet so may be a better downgrade target later on when he gets going
couch and pfeiffer rookie listed atm i think so will have to look at that too.. maybe treloar for pfeiff?
other than that a pretty strong side
little tinkering needed but all in good time 7.5/10

rate mine http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,47605.0.html

[jamesalex]

I like it. Drummond obviously a big risk and having him and Lake in the same defence could be a bit risky but if you are confident in their ability then pick them both. Otherwise it's a solid team in all positions: 8.5/10

Here's mine: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,47594.0.html

[SonsOfZeus]

drummond and lake to risky tbh. i prefer sandi over cox and the 60k will give you 140k toplay around with the backline. everything else looks pretty solid.

[JRizzle]

I like it. Drummond obviously a big risk and having him and Lake in the same defence could be a bit risky but if you are confident in their ability then pick them both. Otherwise it's a solid team in all positions: 8.5/10

Here's mine: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,47594.0.html

Thanks mate! I may remove drummond.
I've rated yours. Good luck.

[Colty]

As others have said Drummond is of course a risk but one that could pay off, im not taking the risk but I certainly think there is merit in gambling on him, same goes with Lake but to a lesser extent as he is not as dear.

im not sold on the Porps, id like to see his form in the nab cup and where here will be playing, if he is just playing up forward his scores wont be to flash.

I like your mids and ruck!

Its a good side though mate I was just chucking a few fairly obvious suggestions up there!

Have a go at mine, its titled Take 2.

[JRizzle]

Based on feedback and evaluating the team, here is the second take on the team.

B Goddard, H Scotland, B Delidio, B Lake, M Clarke, B Ellis, T Mohr
emerg - S Morris, L Brown

S Pendlebury, G Ablett, C Judd, M Barlow, T Adams, S Clifton,
emerg - A Treloar, M Baguley

D Cox, T Goldstein
emerg - J Giles, M Baguley

L Franklin, S Johnson, M Pavlich, A Christensen, J Porplyzia, A Saad, C Hampton
emerg - D Zorko, T Couch

Bank - $104k

Only real concern in Baguley. He is in to create flexibility and allow a swap between mids and backs.
Apart from that - I am happy with the team. I think it is strong and a solid amount of cash in the bank.

Thoughts??? I will rate your team if you take the effort to rate mine. 

[PICCOLLO]

Dont let mpp options jepardise a balanced team.  Orren stephensen should be in every team.  Get him.  Everyone will suffer during the byes but you want guys who'll score and make money.

Your backs are good, mids good, fwds not bad.
Uv got goldy and cox in rucks- do they share first bye?  If they do u gotta ditch one and it should be goldy bcos hmac is in form and will split ruck duites with him and decrease his scoring potential.  Sandilands a better option.

[ben_020285]

Nice team, just needs a little tweaking.

BACKS: Can't have Deledio, Goddard and Scotland because they all share the same bye round. Even with MPP you will still get a donut in round 13. Of that group I would swap Deledio due to the Tigers hard draw early in the season. Heath Shaw would be a good addition.

MIDS: Pendles, Judd, Ablett are great. With Barlow, you have to ask yourself can he be in the top 6 mids this season? If not then I wouldn't have him in there. The high scoring SC teams end up with 6 guns in their mids.

RUCKS: As Piccollo alluded to, you can't have both HMac and Cox in the one side. I would swap HMac out of the two but have a think about the inclusion of Cox too. I think he is very overpriced and Naitanui will surely steal a lot of points from him this season as he continues to improve.

FWDS: Have porps in your side at your peril. Is he a keeper? No. Is he likely to re-injure his shoulder? Yes. I would upgrade him to J Brown.

My suggestions:

In: H Shaw, Gun mid such as J Selwood, 2 rucks that don't share the bye, J Brown

Out: Deledio, Barlow, Cox, Goldstein, Porplyzia

[d_rose1]

Based on feedback and evaluating the team, here is the second take on the team.

B Goddard, H Scotland, B Delidio, B Lake, M Clarke, B Ellis, T Mohr
emerg - S Morris, L Brown

S Pendlebury, G Ablett, C Judd, M Barlow, T Adams, S Clifton,
emerg - A Treloar, M Baguley

D Cox, T Goldstein
emerg - J Giles, M Baguley

L Franklin, S Johnson, M Pavlich, A Christensen, J Porplyzia, A Saad, C Hampton
emerg - D Zorko, T Couch

Bank - $104k

Only real concern in Baguley. He is in to create flexibility and allow a swap between mids and backs.
Apart from that - I am happy with the team. I think it is strong and a solid amount of cash in the bank.

Thoughts??? I will rate your team if you take the effort to rate mine.

super team mate only thing im unsure about is porps (cause i will break down i bet) and chirstensen im not so sold on him maybe try find the money for zaharakis :)
8.5/10  obviously your gonna have to wait till nab to see the rookies

heres mine http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,47680.0.html

[lionsrule888]

I have Drummond too, he used to be one of the top defenders with Goddard sc wise until he was injured. I will watch his nab cup and then decide whether or not to keep him. How come u have 2 baguleys and one in ruck? U could downgrade to o.stephensen from Geelong in ruck and play Giles on the field for that extra 500k which could help a lot elsewhere in your team. Liking your team so far, good luck!

[mpollock]

Drummond must be a no ... get him if he kills it in the first 2 rounds of the season and doesn't get injured.
i would downgrade one of your rucks to upgrade forward line ... smith, kruizer or Mcintosh

Please check out my side if you get a chance.