Would This Swap Make My Team Better?

[Windigo]

I'm thinking about downgrading J.Brown to Winderlich.

Winder has been dominant in the past and everything out of Essendon suggests that he is slaying.

My Idea:

J.Brown>Winderlich & Sidebottom>Fyfe

Then I can go Broughton>Birchall. But not keen.

OR

J.Brown>Winderlich & Sidebottom>Pav/Cloke

Then Broughton>Enright/Shaw/Suckling

Or trade Brown>Winder. Pocket the cash. Or do that and trade Sidebum to Goodes and be done with it.

First option would make my fwds like this:

Franklin,Martin, Fyfe, Gray, Winderlich, Zorko & Walsh

Or don't change anything at at all.  :P

[elephants]

Don't change nothing. Brown is a GUN.

[Holz]

i think brown and sidebottom are great picks so i would keep them. As for broughton i think there are better cheaper option e.g. waters grimes etc..

[theamateur]

Sidebottom for Goodes

[stew42]

Don't change nothing. Brown is a GUN.

+1

[ShaynoB]

Keep as is!!

Not sold on Brown or Winder but if u want 1 i think they will avg pretty similar anyways. Winder might start slow but pick up throughout the season

[Memphistopheles]

Don't do it.

Winderlich is too risky an option imo. Not until I see some form will I consider him and even then he will probably be too pricey.

Although I'm not sold on Brown either. Not going with either in my team.

[Big_Cox14]

I would go and downgrade Brown - Winderlich and upgrade sidebum to Goodes.

Goodes has an easy draw to start and is very durable.

If Winderlich stays on the park he could avg around 85-90 imo. J Brown is more suited to SC with his contested possies and impact on the game, etc imo.

[Just Clancy]

Brown > Winderlich
Steele > Pav
Brought > Birch

[Windigo]

I'm sticking with Brown ATM.

But Winderlich has been a  fairly good scorer in the past. Don't forget that!

I think by downgrading Brown it makes my team better only if Winder can average the 80+ that he is capable of. I'll just wait for NAB to see how Winder is running. But from all accounts he is going pretty good.

Still considering. Broughton>Suckling is what I'd try and do. Only about 4 grand off him.

[Craark]

I'm sticking with Brown ATM.

+1