Ferrari vs Skyline

[Phasir]

  Okay, so here I have a dilemma, every year I start off planning my DT with smooth moving, leaders of men, type players who dominate at DT, however I when Feb.1 comes around it turns into "who's the most underpriced premo I can get my hands on"
So, the question is, do I go a smooth moving, top notch, classy midfield like a Ferrari or go the over-analysed, slightly cheaper, but capable of scoring similarly, Skyline?
Ferrari: Pendlebury, Ablett, Rockliff, Gibbs, Barlow, rookie/ rookie rookie.   (around $10k left)
Skyline: Ablett, Rockliff, Barlow, Hayes, rookie, rookie/ rookie rookie.  (with a massive hunk of Salary Cap for upgrades later)