Smokey Forward - Setanta

[Cruiseon]

A lot of discussion going on around J Brown (whom I'll be locking in my team) but another one that might be worth some discussion is Setanta O'Hailpan.

Now I was not his biggest fan & perhaps this discussion would be better if his price was $300k rather than $377k BUT there are quite a few positives. He has always been quite sound physically, you would think he'll play nearly every game as a target and to provide a bigger body, and even if GWS are getting beaten he does know where the goals are. Will a good run at senior level provide the consistency he was always afer at Carlton?

Maybe? Maybe not?   Thoughts?

[kilbluff1985]

Nah not worth it imo ball wont get down there enough and when it does delivery wont be great.

Better GWS forwards to look at imo Hampton, Cameron, Treloar

[meow meow]

With Brogan who'll no doubt get injured at some stage as the main ruck, Santa could do a fair bit of ruck work with Giles.

What price is he?

[Cruiseon]

$377k, which is probably a little higher than it should be.

[ubeaut]

Way too expensive. I'd rather Folau. At least 250 k cheaper. And while Setanta gives his all Folau has much more talent.